We Blind-Tasted Buffalo Trace And Picked A Surprise Favorite

Send us Fan MailWhat happens when you line up four Buffalo Trace pours—two store barrel picks and two standard releases—and taste them blind? We set the table with numbered glasses, a few strong opinions, and a lot of curiosity, then let our palates do the talking. The result: clear favorites, a couple of surprises, and a deeper respect for how consistency and character can both shine in a bourbon lineup.We start with a nod to Detroit’s evolving scene, from a hidden speakeasy behind a cooler door to the energy pulsing through neighborhood spots. Then we pay tribute to Freddie Johnson, the beloved Buffalo Trace storyteller whose family promise and warmth inspired us to make this a Trace-focused happy hour. Along the way, we unpack the brand’s roots, from river shipments to Colonel E. H. Taylor’s push for standards, and why that history still matters when you pick a bottle off the shelf today.The tasting itself is where the fun takes off. One pour hits with extra spice and depth—classic “store pick” swagger. Another leans into the dependable Buffalo Trace profile: balanced caramel, soft oak, a comfortable finish. Side by side, the differences become vivid and personal. We debate whether airline minis differ from 750s, talk proof and palate, and confront the pricing paradox that turns fair MSRPs into chase bottles. Most importantly, we celebrate opening bottles instead of hoarding them—especially when signatures and sales help good causes like cemetery restoration tied to Freddie’s work.If you love bourbon, Buffalo Trace, Detroit cocktail culture, or you’re just bourbon-curious, this one’s for you. Hit play to hear the full blind reveal, our favorites, and a few travel and community stories that keep the glasses clinking. If you dig the vibe, subscribe, share with a whiskey‑loving friend, and drop your pick for best value bourbon—we’ll shout out our favorite takes next week.Support the showhttps://linktr.ee/ManCaveHappyHourwww.ManCaveHappyHour.comJamie Flanagan @DJJamieDetroitMatt Fox @fox_beazlefoxAugust Gitschlag @rawgustoMerch www.WearingFunny.com