What Makes The Best Board Game Expansions?

Do we want more? Do we want less? What do we want when we play a new expansion to a board game? We give our thoughts on what makes a great board game expansions with some examples of our favorites and our least favorites on this week’s edition of The Cardboard Herald Podcast

An episode of the The Cardboard Herald podcast, hosted by Eric Moots, titled "What Makes The Best Board Game Expansions?" was published on April 20, 2025 and runs 103 minutes.

April 20, 2025 ·103m · The Cardboard Herald

0:00 / 0:00

Summary

Do we want more? Do we want less? What do we want when we play a new expansion to a board game? We give our thoughts on what makes a great board game expansions with some examples of our favorites and our least favorites on this week’s edition of The Cardboard Herald Podcast 0:00 - Introductions and What We’ve Played This Week 11:08 - Our Topic This Week: What Makes a Great Board Game Expansions 31:15 - Eric’s Number 5: 7 Wonders Duel: Pantheon 34:48 - Jack’s Number 5: Architects of the West Kingdom: Works of Wonder 38:24 - Eric’s Number 4: Spirit Island: Jagged Earth 40:37 - Jack’s Number 4: Spirit Island: Jagged Earth 43:33 - Eric’s Number 3: Dune Imperium: Rise of Ix 52:38 - Jack’s Number 3: Viticulture Tuscany Essential Edition 1:00:54 - Eric’s Number 2: Arcs: Blighted Reach Campaign 1:09:01 - Jack’s Number 2: Undaunted: Reinforcements 1:16:02 - Eric’s Number 1: Wingspan Oceania 1:22:06 - Jack’s Number 1:Terraforming Mars Prelude 1:27:11 - What Do We Want An Expansion of Harmonies to Look Like? 1:32:34 - Listener Comments! 01:41:13 - Outro!

Episode Description

Do we want more? Do we want less? What do we want when we play a new expansion to a board game? We give our thoughts on what makes a great board game expansions with some examples of our favorites and our least favorites on this week’s edition of The Cardboard Herald Podcast

0:00 - Introductions and What We’ve Played This Week

11:08 - Our Topic This Week: What Makes a Great Board Game Expansions

31:15 - Eric’s Number 5: 7 Wonders Duel: Pantheon

34:48 - Jack’s Number 5: Architects of the West Kingdom: Works of Wonder

38:24 - Eric’s Number 4: Spirit Island: Jagged Earth

40:37 - Jack’s Number 4: Spirit Island: Jagged Earth

43:33 - Eric’s Number 3: Dune Imperium: Rise of Ix

52:38 - Jack’s Number 3: Viticulture Tuscany Essential Edition

1:00:54 - Eric’s Number 2: Arcs: Blighted Reach Campaign

1:09:01 - Jack’s Number 2: Undaunted: Reinforcements

1:16:02 - Eric’s Number 1: Wingspan Oceania

1:22:06 - Jack’s Number 1:Terraforming Mars Prelude

1:27:11 - What Do We Want An Expansion of Harmonies to Look Like?

1:32:34 - Listener Comments!

01:41:13 - Outro!

Share this episode

Similar Episodes

#337 When the Conflict at Work and the Conflict at Home Are the Same Conflict

Apr 11, 2026 ·10m

Don't Be Lazy | JLP Fri 4-10-26

Apr 10, 2026 ·180m

Seeing Trials Through Seasoned Eyes #1

Apr 10, 2026 ·34m

#336 The Conversation You Were Afraid Of Was Never About What You Thought

Apr 10, 2026 ·9m

What Does It Take to Enter Heaven While You Live? | JLP Thu 4-9-26

Apr 9, 2026 ·180m

The Importance of Jesus' Ascension #2

Apr 9, 2026 ·34m

Similar Podcasts

Pushing Cardboard Grant Linneberg Talk about historical boardgames and boardgaming. Tabletop conflict simulation boardgames, from old school hex-and-counter to modern card driven games and beyond. If it's a historical game, a political game, or a wargame, we'll talk about it.We dive into specific games in detail each episode, with tips on how to play and how the game fits in with other similar games. As well, we usually have an interview with a designer or publisher. And finally, we have news from the history gaming world as well as tips for new players and general chatter about what's happening in the hobby we love. The UnNoticed Entrepreneur Jim James Business marketing for entrepreneurs.I talk with entrepreneurs and experts about how to build a brand and generate more leads.My name is Jim James. I've built my own companies on 3 continents since 1995 , including a multi office public relations agency. On the show I bring you tools and tactics that you can put into practice on the same day.I also publish a magazine and newsletter.Please visit and sign up to stay up to date:https://www.theunnoticedentrepreneur.com The Recalibration Julie Holly The Recalibration is a daily podcast for driven professionals who aren’t falling apart, but are quietly tired of holding everything together.A space for nervous system informed identity recalibration before burnout forces the issue.The Recalibration with Julie Holly is a daily podcast for high-performing professionals, leaders, and driven humans who are successful on paper, but feel worn down, disconnected, or quietly misaligned inside.Often, this isn’t because something is wrong.It’s because their nervous system has been carrying more than it was designed to hold.This show is for people who:Keep functioning at a high level, even when it costs them.Feel tired of hacks, habits, and strategies that no longer work.Aren’t in crisis, but know something isn’t sustainable.Sense clarity slipping even though effort remains strong.<b The 15 Minute Book Club Alex Churchill, Matt Bone We don't always have an hour or so to spare. In this new, short-form podcast, Alex and Matt interview an author, gameshow style, and they have fifteen minutes on the clock to convince you to buy their new book. With a minute to go, the alarm sounds and your hosts will throw out the meanest, saddest comment they think the internet will come up with about the book and the author gets a chance to respond.Patreon members get extra time: 15 more minutes in which you get to see behind the scenes and find out how the book was written. You can subscribe here: https://www.patreon.com/cw/15MinuteBookClubWatch the video version: https://www.youtube.com/@15MinuteBook_ClubBuy the book (UK) <a href="https://uk.bookshop.org/shop/15MinuteBookClub" rel="noopener noreferre

URL copied to clipboard!