When Autistic Masking Teaches You to Distrust Yourself
from 🎙️ Lov(ette) or Leave It Hosted by Lovette Jallow
This morning, I was sitting with my coffee thinking about how much quieter and peaceful my life has become since I started paying attention to my own autistic unmasking journey. When unmasked I spend far less time arguing myself out of things I have already noticed, far less time trying to make contradictory information behave simply because somebody else seems comfortable with the contradiction. Somewhere in that ordinary little morning thought, I realised I had been approaching the question of autism and abuse from the wrong direction. I keep seeing autistic people say that we are too literal, too pattern-driven, too direct, too resistant to inconsistency to be successfully manipulated. Sometimes the claim goes further: autistic people are “too autistic for narcissists.” I understand why that idea can feel reassuring, especially when it comes from survivors trying to make sense of what happened to them and searching for something in themselves that feels protective. The problem is what the claim implies for everyone else. If autism supposedly protects us from manipulation, then an autistic person who was gaslit, coerced, controlled or abused is left carrying another accusation on top of the harm itself: perhaps they failed to recognise the pattern, failed to trust their autism, failed somehow to be autistic correctly. People also forget that Neurodivergence is an umbrella, not a moral category. Autistic people can also have NPD, and people with NPD can be autistic. Abuse is not a diagnostic criterion for NPD, and the diagnosis alone does not tell you whether someone is abusive. That does not fit what we know about autistic people and abuse. Autistic adults experience sexual, physical and emotional violence at rates far above the general population, with autistic women facing particularly high levels of victimisation. And yet something genuinely did change for me when I stopped suppressing so much of the way my brain naturally processes information. I became less willing to smooth over contradictions, less likely to assume that confusion automatically meant I had misunderstood, and more comfortable leaving a question unresolved until the information made sense. Those two things can exist together. Autism does not make us immune to abuse, and some autistic traits can still affect how certain abusive tactics work once we stop automatically suppressing them. That tension is where my essay begins. Why Are Autistic People Vulnerable to Abuse? It requires only that the cost of pursuing the question stays higher than the cost of dropping it. Autistic adults report sexual harassment, sexual violence and physical violence at substantially higher rates than non-autistic adults, and the vulnerability grows through isolation, dependency, stigma, constrained access to support and years of being taught that our interpretation of other people is less reliable than theirs. The comparison matters because it cuts through the idea that autism somehow makes us unusually difficult to manipulate. In a cross-sectional study by Vicki Gibbs, Jennie Hudson and Elizabeth Pellicano, 118 autistic adults were compared with 110 non-autistic adults. Sexual harassment was reported by 75.4 percent of the autistic group and 56.4 percent of the non-autistic group. Sexual violence was reported by 56.8 percent of autistic participants and 28.2 percent of non-autistic participants. Physical violence showed the same pattern, 58.5 percent compared with 36.4 percent. Among women, 61 percent of autistic women reported sexual violence compared with 34.5 percent of non-autistic women, while 54.5 percent reported physical violence compared with 28.6 percent of non-autistic women. Those figures need methodological context, and I would rather give it myself than have somebody else supply it for me. The study used an online survey and recruited autistic participants through autism organisations, Facebook groups, personal networks and snowball sampling, so selection bias is possible and the sample cannot be treated as a population prevalence estimate. A systematic review published in 2024 found wide variation across sixteen studies because researchers used different definitions, measures, populations and time periods.2 Even with that variation, five of the seven studies that directly compared autistic and non-autistic adults found significantly higher rates of at least one form of violence among autistic participants. The other two did not, which is worth saying plainly because whilst the direction of the evidence is consistent. Its precision is not. The more interesting question is why. Research in this area remains thinner than the scale of the problem warrants, and the systematic review itself criticises how often studies focus on the autistic person’s traits while giving far less attention to negative stereotyping, institutional neglect and the absence of meaningful protection. Social isolation can reduce witnesses and routes out. Financial or care dependency can make leaving materially dangerous. Communication differences can make ambiguous behaviour harder to resolve. Repeated correction teaches many autistic people to examine themselves first when something feels wrong. Add the experience of being told throughout childhood, school, healthcare and work that your tone was wrong, your reaction was excessive, your interpretation was too literal or your discomfort was inappropriate, and self-doubt acquires a history long before an abusive person arrives. It is worth saying plainly what the person on the other side of this arrangement is getting, because an essay that stays inside the experience of the person being harmed can make abuse sound like weather. Somebody who can keep you explaining yourself gets several things at once. They get to carry on behaving exactly as they have been behaving, because a conversation about whether you understood correctly is a conversation that never arrives at what they did. They get your labour, the hours spent reconstructing timelines, rehearsing how to raise something without provoking a reaction, and managing their mood so that the subject can be approached at all. They get to decide which version of events stands. And where money, housing, immigration status, medication, care or access to children runs through them, all of that is backed by the knowledge that leaving is expensive. None of it requires a diagnosis, a personality type or a plan. It requires only that the cost of pursuing the question stays higher than the cost of dropping it. Vulnerability here describes exposure, power and restricted options, which is why it belongs in a sentence about what perpetrators select for rather than in a sentence about what autistic people lack. This is also why I have become increasingly wary of the commercial recovery culture that overlaps with neurodivergent spaces. The structure is consistent enough to describe without naming anybody. A piece of content tells autistic people that our pattern recognition, our rigidity, our directness make us unusually resistant to manipulation. The claim lands as recognition for many, because many of us have spent our lives being told those same traits are defects. What follows the claim is a quiz, a coaching package, a membership on identifying the people we have supposedly already been equipped to identify. What is being sold is certainty. The immunity story works commercially because it flatters the buyer’s cognition and then, in the same breath, creates the anxiety only the seller can settle: if your perception is that good, why did this happen to you, and how will you know next time? Somebody who feel… This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit lovettejallow.substack.com/subscribe
Embed this episode
No transcript yet.