PodParley PodParley

When Copy Gets Real: Why Getting Too Creative Actually Kills Conversion

Is sounding "enterprise" killing your marketing message? In this episode, conversion copywriter Jessica Malnik joins the crew to expose why the most effective copy isn't about being clever—it's about stealing your customers' exact words. We dive in...

Episode 8 of the We're Not Marketers podcast, hosted by Gabriel Bujold, Eric Holland, Zach Roberts, titled "When Copy Gets Real: Why Getting Too Creative Actually Kills Conversion" was published on April 24, 2025 and runs 26 minutes.

April 24, 2025 ·26m · We're Not Marketers

0:00 / 0:00

Is sounding "enterprise" killing your marketing message? In this episode, conversion copywriter Jessica Malnik joins the crew to expose why the most effective copy isn't about being clever—it's about stealing your customers' exact words.


We dive into customer research plays you can use now, why corporate speak is a conversion killer, and how LinkedIn "lunatics" sacrifice credibility for clicks. Tune in for practical tips on creating content that actually converts instead of just sounding smart.


What you get when you listen

  • Why product marketers are the "Swiss army knife" of marketing (and why that's a good thing)

  • The surprisingly simple research hack top copywriters use to write enterprise copy that doesn't sound robotic

  • The hidden Reddit goldmine most marketers completely overlook

  • How AI can help you analyze 1,000+ customer comments in minutes (including the exact prompts to use)

  • Why Jessica refuses to work with pre-revenue startups (and what this means for your messaging)

  • The embarrassing LinkedIn trend that's landing marketers on the "LinkedIn Lunatic" subreddit

  • Why "What's in it for them?" trumps creativity every single time

  • The counterintuitive reason why Jessica actually prefers clients with no messaging brief

  • The three types of LinkedIn posts that drive real business (not just vanity metrics)


Show Notes

00:00 Introduction and Guest Introduction

01:47 Jessica Malnick on Product Marketing

03:36 Navigating Copywriting Challenges

08:34 Human Touch in Copywriting

10:08 Using Reddit for Audience Research

11:27 Tools and Techniques for Copywriting

18:34 LinkedIn Strategies for PMMs

23:05 Final Thoughts and Resources

26:16 Conclusion and Sign-Off


  • Why being human in your copy matters more in the age of AI than ever before


Hosted on Ausha. See ausha.co/privacy-policy for more information.

Seas the Movement Jo Hurford Dive in and be inspired to start or continue your journey in conservation. In this podcast, we're chatting with digital producers, marketers, educators, researchers and anyone who, either professionally or personally, makes environmentally conscious actions and decisions. There are many threats facing our natural world. It's not always easy and sometimes you feel alone, but there are many of us doing what we can. No one is without power. Be inspired to seas the movement. Becoming Her Marketing Merina Coopoosamy Welcome to Becoming Her Marketing, hosted by Merina Coopoosamy. This is not just a podcast, it’s a movement designed to help YOU BECOME THAT GIRL in business.Here Merina, a digital marketer with 7 years experience in the industry talks about women empowerment in business, all things life, self improvement and how you can launch your business through digital marketing. Come join this journey, and become the entrepreneur you were destined to be. We're Not Gonna Make it We're Not Gonna Make It We're Not Gonna Make It is a podcast hosted by Stamati Arakas and Jason Flood. The podcast is about being low level comics in LA and dealing with the hard reality that they will probably never make it. Each week they have a new guest and they talk to them about the LA comedy scene and most importantly ask them if they think they will make it as a comedian. We're Not Talking About That The Guys Embark on a hilarious journey of meandering conversations with “We’re Not Talking About That,” the podcast where three Gen X maestros—Gordon, T-Bone, and Gabe—dive into topics nobody should talk about and somehow never quite find the point. Join this trio of opinionated wanderers as they navigate the labyrinth of life’s absurdities, armed with humor, sarcasm, and a healthy dose of Generation X wisdom. From nostalgic rants to offbeat musings, expect the unexpected on each episode. Because, let’s face it, not all who wander are lost—some are just having a darn good time not finding their way. Tu
URL copied to clipboard!