Why Federal Appeal Waivers Rarely Break
from Swear on the Stand Hosted by Daniel W. Swear
Rashon Harris appealed his 240-month prison sentence for a methamphetamine conviction after the Fifth Circuit previously dismissed his case based on an appeal waiver. Following the Supreme Court's ruling in Hunter v. United States—which established that appeal waivers are unenforceable only if they result in a severe miscarriage of justice—the case was remanded for further review. Harris argued that his waiver was invalid because he pled guilty on the same day as his initial appearance and that a sentencing enhancement for reckless flight constituted an egregious error. However, the court determined that Harris knowingly and voluntarily accepted the plea agreement and that any potential calculation mistake regarding his sentencing guidelines constituted a standard error rather than a miscarriage of justice. Consequently, the court enforced the appeal waiver and dismissed the case.
Embed this episode
No transcript yet.