Why Some Murder Cases Are Never Solved with Andrew Rule

What happens when a veteran crime journalist revisits one of Australia’s most haunting unsolved murders?In this episode, I sit down with Andrew Rule, one of Australia’s most respected crime reporters and storytellers, to talk about the unsolved murders of Margaret and Seana Tapp. Andrew shares what first drew him to the case decades ago, the troubling missteps in the original investigation, and why this story has continued to stay with him throughout his career.We explore the complexities of storytelling when real families, reputations, and unanswered questions are involved. Andrew reflects on the ethical responsibility of journalists and podcasters covering true crime, the difference between suspicion and proof, and how human behaviour, relationships, and risk can shape criminal investigations.As someone who personally knew Seana and Margie, this conversation is deeply personal for me. Together, we discuss how cases can remain unsolved for decades, why witnesses sometimes only speak years later, and the emotional weight carried by families still searching for answers.Remember; You may not be ready to die, but at least you can be prepared.Take care,CatherineListen to Andrew's episodes about the Tapp murders:The Tapp tragedy revisited: Part 1The Tapp tragedy revisited: Part 2Connect With Andrew RuleRead more about his work and life: https://www.heraldsun.com.au/journalists/andrew-ruleListen to his podcast: Life & Crimes with Andrew Rule https://podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/life-and-crimes-with-andrew-rule/id1260800644We'd love to hear from you. Send us a text :-)Death is hard, make death admin easy with the Critical Info Platform. It’s a simple, secure system that helps you prepare and share your legacy, wishes and personal paperwork.It’s packed with prompts, guides and even a To Do List to help you easily gather critical information for a complete end-of-life plan.Leave behind a legacy, not a mess.Sign up now to your free trial at critical info.com.auNo credit card needed. Every Tuesday at 7pm, I host Critical Chat Tuesdays — free, online conversations where you can ask questions or just listen.No pressure. No expectation.Because this isn’t about planning for “someday” — it’s about being ready for whatever life throws your way.Join anytime at criticalinfo.com.au/events MY LOVED ONE HAS DIED, WHAT DO I DO NOW?Our guide, ‘My Loved One Has Died, What Do I Do Now?’ provides practical steps for the hours and days after a loved one's death. Download it here.SUPPORT SERVICESIf you're feeling overwhelmed by grief, find support through our resources and bereavement services here.Support the showSupport the 'Don’t Be Caught Dead' podcast with a one-off or regular donation to help Critical Info, a certified social enterprise, keep creating free, high-impact conversations about death, grief and planning—every contribution fuels our mission to reduce the burden on families and build a more death-literate, compassionate community. Donate here now.Learn more: https://criticalinfo.com.au/Connect with Don't Be Caught Dead podcast host Catherine Ashton & Critical info on socials:https://linktr.ee/catherine_critical_info?utm_source=linktree_profile_share&ltsid=c1879300-84db-4c70-9270-18d17d3ec22aMusic composer: Ania Reynolds - https://www.aniareynolds.com/