Skip to content
Mystics & Mulder podcast artwork

PODCAST · religion

Mystics & Mulder

by Mystics & Mulder

Mystics & Mulder is a podcast at the intersection of pop culture and faith by Sarah and Maeve. Music by Moshun.

Publisher-supplied feed metadata · PodParley refreshed Feb 23, 2026 · Source feed

Episodes

  1. Hozier

    Long overdue, it’s our Theology of Hozier episode! Sarah and Maeve discuss our favorite forest creature’s discography, literary and musical themes, and music videos. We touch on how Hozier portrays death, despair, hope, radical joy, and more.

  2. Stranger Things and the Problem of Evil

    Friends don't lie--they make podcasts! Sarah, Maeve, and special guest Kristen talk about the problem of evil and how it manifests in Netflix's Stranger Things. We cover all four seasons and get into supernatural vs. human evil, sacrifice in the show, Eleven's powers, and much more. Listen…

    more
  3. Tarot

    Mystics & Mulder cover a long-awaited topic: tarot decks and readings! Join Sarah, Maeve, and special guest Nicole as we dive into the history, spiritual and contemplative practices, and pop culture representations of tarot. Tags: tarot, tarot cards, tarot decks, tarot readings, spirituality,...

  4. Taize

    We’re back! Grab your chocolate sticks and songbook, folks. Sarah and Maeve discuss our pilgrimages to Taizé, an ecumenical Christian community of music, prayer, and simple living in France. Listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Anchor, or wherever you find podcasts!

  5. Disney Theology

    It’s the happiest episode on earth! Tune in for Disney Theology as we discuss Lilo & Stitch, The Princess and the Frog, and Mulan.

  6. Sacred Friendship

    What if the real treasure at the end was the friends we made along the way? We discuss representations of sacred friendship and relationship anarchy with BFFs Caroline and Elizabeth, writers for the blog @talesfromthehart. Favorite friendships in literature and pop culture? Booksmart, Ruth and...

  7. Hadestown

    All aboard! We're going way down to Hadestown and discussing the musical’s big emotions, casting choices, and theology with special guest and theatre extraordinaire Sophie. Yes, we do now own the rights to Hadestown 2, a musical set in Eurydice and Persephone’s anti-capitalist speakeasy starring...

  8. Music & Theology of Johnny Flynn

    Are you there, Johnny? It's us, Sarah and Maeve. We discuss the music and theology of actor, musician, singer-songwriter, and potential Dumpster-diver Johnny Flynn.

  9. Sister Act & Church Music

    Brace yourself, sisters! Sarah and Maeve chat about Sister Act with our dear friend, talented musician, and PK, Clara! Topics include hymnal adaptations, ministry revitalization, appropriation, and denominational differences in music and worship. Come for Whoopi, stay for the early 2000s…

    more
  10. Sacred Reading w. Vanessa Zoltan: Praying With Jane Eyre

    Sarah and Maeve chat with Vanessa Zoltan, chaplain, author of the new book "Praying With Jane Eyre," and host of the podcasts "Harry Potter and the Sacred Text," "Hot & Bothered," and "The Real Question!" We discuss sacred reading, literature, and our favorite novel, "Jane Eyre." Digressions...

  11. Godspell

    Your favorite Presbyterians and our favorite Catholic (Brody!) reunite to chat about Jesus Christ Superstar and Godspell in this two-parter! In this episode, we focus on Godspell. Go to the previous episode for our Jesus Christ Superstar musings. Cw: racism, police/military violence, death, clowns

  12. Jesus Christ Superstar

    Your favorite Presbyterians and our favorite Catholic (Brody!) reunite to chat about Jesus Christ Superstar and Godspell in this two-parter! This episode focuses mostly on Jesus Christ Superstar. Go to the next episode to listen to our Godspell musings. Cw: clowns, racism, police/military…

    more
  13. Lent and Fasting

    It’s Lent season! Sarah, Maeve, and special guest Haley discuss the history and theology of Lent, contemporary spiritual discipleship and fasting, and our own Lenten journeys. CW: disordered eating and eating disorders, diet culture, fasting, food

  14. Tech Sabbath

    Sarah and Maeve talk about sabbaths, rest, and taking a break from screens and media. Tangents include driving through school zones and that rainbow parachute from second grade.

  15. Werewolves and Vampires

    Happy Halloween! In this silly, spooky episode, Sarah and Maeve discuss their favorite supernaturals: werewolves and vampires. Ft. Penny Dreadful, Teen Wolf, Twilight, The Vampire Diaries, Interview with the Vampire, Moonlight, What We Do In The Shadows, Parasol Protectorate, Jane Eyre…

    more
  16. Christianity & Prison Abolition w. Abolition Apostles

    Sarah and Maeve interview Abolition Apostles leaders Sarah Pritchard and David Brazil about faith-based prison ministry and abolition and media representations of the prison and criminal justice systems. Ft. a very cute baby. CW: incarceration, abuse, assault

  17. Purity Culture

    Sarah, Maeve, and Brent talk purity culture: sex, drugs, Twilight, and Jerry Falwell. CW: drugs, addiction, prison, sex, queerphobia, abuse, trauma, food, fatphobia

  18. Myths & Legends

    We bring you a legendary episode of Mystics & Mulder! Your hosts and special guest Carlina discuss Orpheus and Eurydice, The Cannibal of Qemer, and The Táin's Queen Medb and Cú Chulainn. Ft. Woodchuck Todd, Maneater by Hall & Oates, and tears courtesy of Hadestown.

  19. Fanfiction

    Yes, it’s our longest episode to date, and, no, we’re not sorry. Sarah, Maeve, Grace, and Will discuss the joy and complexity of fanfiction as a medium of representation and creativity. This episode is for novices and aFICionados alike.

  20. The Good Place

    Welcome! Everything is fine. Sarah, Maeve, and special guest Bethany discuss the philosophy and theology of The Good Place and how the beloved show breaks down impact vs. intent, promotes community care and collective goodness, and critiques social inaction.

  21. Black Theologians & Theologians of Color

    In honor of Black Lives Matter, Sarah, Maeve, and a few friends in ministry discuss the prolific works of Black theologians, including William Barber, James Cone, Katie Geneva Cannon, and Emilie Townes, and theologians of color regarding their impact on our personal theologies. Check out and…

    more
  22. Dungeons & Dragons

    Roll for initiative! Joined by our very own DM, Liv, Sarah and Maeve get into the power of community, world-building, faith/fate, and storytelling for players of Dungeons & Dragons.

  23. Let’s Talk About Death, Baby!

    Sarah and Maeve get into a topic that most people don’t really like talking about: death! From attitudes towards death and dying in medieval Iberia to Caitlin Doughty’s “Ask a Mortician,” we discuss physical representations of death and Death, Western cultural and religious taboos and traditions,...

  24. Psychics, Seances, Spiritualism, & Mediums

    Ahoy, ahoy! It's a psychic's life for us here at Mystics & Mulder. Sarah and Maeve discuss all things related to psychics and mediums in this episode, including fortune telling, palm reading, and the history of seances and spiritualism. We get into how cultural anxieties, social movements, gender...

  25. Ghost Hunting, Paranormal Entertainment, & Dark Tourism

    Join us on a mystical renaissance as we investigate ghost hunting, paranormal entertainment, and dark tourism. Why are we drawn to ghosts and connecting with the afterlife? Sarah and Maeve analyze how these industries may intersect with gender, class, and cultural anxieties. We feature Ghost...

  26. Sisters & Nuns in Popular Culture

    Welcome to Episode 2 of Mystics & Mulder! Listen to your two favorite Presbyterians and *our* favorite token Catholic as we discuss representations of nuns in popular culture (American Horror Story, Derry Girls, The Sound of Music, Sister Act, Call the Midwife) along with the work of actual…

    more
  27. The X-Files: The One That Started It All

    Coming to an astral projection near you: it's Mystics & Mulder! Welcome to the first episode of the podcast. Co-hosts Sarah and Maeve discuss faith, belief, trust, religion, and otherness in The X-Files, the show that started it all for us. It's time to get Spooky (and Scully!). Email us at...

Type above to search every episode's transcript for a word or phrase. Matches are scoped to this podcast.

Searching…

We're indexing this podcast's transcripts for the first time — this can take a minute or two. We'll show results as soon as they're ready.

No matches for "" in this podcast's transcripts.

Showing of matches

No topics indexed yet for this podcast.

Loading reviews...

ABOUT THIS SHOW

Mystics & Mulder is a podcast at the intersection of pop culture and faith by Sarah and Maeve. Music by Moshun.

HOSTED BY

Mystics & Mulder

CATEGORIES

Frequently Asked Questions

How many episodes does Mystics & Mulder have?

Mystics & Mulder currently has 27 episodes available on PodParley. New episodes are automatically indexed when they're published to the podcast feed.

What is Mystics & Mulder about?

Mystics & Mulder is a podcast at the intersection of pop culture and faith by Sarah and Maeve. Music by Moshun.

How often does Mystics & Mulder release new episodes?

Mystics & Mulder has 27 episodes. Check the episode list to see recent publication dates and frequency.

Where can I listen to Mystics & Mulder?

You can listen to Mystics & Mulder on PodParley by clicking any episode. We provide an embedded audio player for direct listening, and you can also subscribe via your preferred podcast app using the RSS feed.

Who hosts Mystics & Mulder?

Mystics & Mulder is created and hosted by Mystics & Mulder.
URL copied to clipboard!