Rated P For Paranormal

Episodes

1. 127

   Home Is Where The Pod Is

   In celebration of Matty's return the boys share their TOP 3 Coming Home Moments in film history, and not knowing each other's picks, they actually both had one film in common. But what movie?? Tony & Matty also share a personal coming home moment.

   May 30, 2026

   12m
2. 126

   Matty’s Got Seoul

   A micro episode w/ Matty recording from South Korea. The boys give their T3 Forest Scenes in film history.

   May 21, 2026

   8m
3. 125

   THE TRAIL with Jake Robards

   In this very special episode, Jake Robards shares about his father Jason, his incredible career and drops great stories about A Boy and His Dog. Tony joins in with thoughts about his famous father as well. Just an incredible episode!

   May 13, 2026

   53m
4. 124

   SPECIAL REPORT: The Missing Scientists

   Tony & Matty address the potentially disturbing phenomena of the growing number of missing scientists. Matty sets the stage for Tony, who makes intriguing connections to film and beyond…

   May 7, 2026

   9m
5. 123

   A BOY AND HIS DAWG

   Miami Vice K-9 Unit. Or something. With special guest The Puppy Bowl Ref DAN SCHACHNER!

   Apr 28, 2026

   1h 03m
6. 122

   THE BEST THING WE SAW THIS WINTER

   In this special episode, Tony and Matty each reveal the best thing they watched during this long, cold, brutal winter of 2026!

   Apr 23, 2026

   8m
7. 121

   KPOP DEMON HUNTERS

   Two olds enter the world of K-pop. This should go well.

   Apr 17, 2026

   55m
8. 120

   This Island Earth

   We only want to help you humans! Stop punching us.

   Mar 26, 2026

   1h 12m
9. 119

   THEM!

   Did a giant ant eat little Matty’s giant street pretzel? Or was that Elliot Gould? All will be revealed in this episode! It’s 1954’s THEM!

   Jan 17, 2026

   1h 11m
10. 118

    Amelia Campbell from The Chair Company

    A very special episode! We sit down once again with Amelia Campbell, from the new hit show: The Chair Company (& she’s Tony’s wife!) Merry Christmas and see you in 2026!

    Dec 18, 2025

    58m
11. 117

    TOGETHER

    Did this one stick with us? Let’s find out, all together now. Plus T3 bathroom stalls. Nice barnduminium, babe.

    Dec 15, 2025

    1h 15m
12. 116

    Deadly Friend

    Owen doesn’t have any friends, but you sure do: Tony & Matty! And they’re gonna guide you through this 80’s lost gem. Plus top three balls in film history.

    Nov 27, 2025

    1h 32m
13. 115

    Mausoleum

    Wanna dance?

    Nov 14, 2025

    1h 29m
14. 114

    2025 HALLOWEEN SPECIAL w/ PuppyBowl Ref Dan Schachner

    Hold on to your pumpkins

    Oct 30, 2025

    1h 07m
15. 113

    REC

    REC means record. NO MATTER WHAT !! Plus T3 Shoe Shots in film history.

    Oct 22, 2025

    1h 15m
16. 112

    Things Herd & Scene

    For the first time, in P4P history, the boys were issued a challenge: could they sit through & then discuss the 2021 film Things Heard & Seen. Challenge accepted.

    Oct 13, 2025

    1h 12m
17. 111

    Phantasm

    Check out our phantastic new ep Phantasm ! Plus: Top 3 ManTails in philm history!

    Oct 1, 2025

    1h 22m
18. 110

    The Arrival

    We have discovered a truly hidden 90’s gem for all time.

    Sep 23, 2025

    1h 09m
19. 109

    Apollo 18

    Did you know there was a secret mission to the moon? Neither did we. It didn’t turn out too well. But did the found footage style film about it turn out ok? We’re no rocket scientists’ …but we’ll try to explain.

    Sep 8, 2025

    54m
20. 108

    THE MONKEY

    The boys argue over Osgood Perkins film THE MONKEY

    Sep 8, 2025

    54m
21. 107

    Revelations

    The boys receive a Revelation from S Korea. Or DO they…? And Tony has UAP footage! Plus: Top 3 Body Dumps in film history,

    May 29, 2025

    58m
22. 106

    Presence

    Great Led Zeppelin record. But how’s the movie? Plus Top Three O.J. moments in film history. The drink not the killer guy.

    Apr 16, 2025

    1h 00m
23. 105

    HOT FROSTY w/ the Puppy Bowl Ref

    The boys review HOT FROSTY w/ Puppy Bowl Ref Dan Schachner. Plus Top 3 Scarves in film history. AND the first ever P4P Quiz!

    Dec 19, 2024

    1h 32m
24. 104

    Poltergeist 2 & Top 3 Station Wagons

    Poltergeist 2 the RePolterying

    Dec 10, 2024

    1h 26m
25. 103

    The Sentinel & Top 3 Contact Lensed Eyes

    What is exactly is the Sentinel..? That is not rhetorical, we were actually hoping you could help us out with that one. PLUS! Tony's hat causes problems. AND the Top 3 Contact Lensed Eyes in Film history. HAPPY THANKSGIVING!

    Nov 27, 2024

    1h 22m
26. 102

    Nosferatu & Top 3 "Can This Be Over Now" Love Moments in film history

    Ve Vant To Suck Yer Blood. Just lie there and enjoy it if you can. It'll be over soon. PLUS! Tony gets mad at Matty's reaction to Werner Herzog's version. AND! Our Top 3 "Can This Be Over Now?" Love Scenes in film history.

    Nov 15, 2024

    1h 16m
27. 101

    John Carpenter's HALLOWEEN & Top 3 Dumb Boyfriends

    HAPPY HALLOWEEN p4p 'ers! Not so much review, as tribute. Love, Tony & Matty

    Oct 28, 2024

    1h 17m
28. 100

    FRIDAY THE 13th & Top 3 Crazy Moms in Film

    The true horror is how many times Matty has mentioned he is 1 degree of Kevin Bacon.

    Oct 24, 2024

    1h 14m
29. 99

    DREAMSCAPE & Top 3 Sweaty Presidents

    Coke fueled V-neck sprints, sweaty president and NORM! This 80's nightmare has it all!

    Oct 16, 2024

    1h 22m
30. 98

    30 Coins & T3 Bad Babies

    Will Matty freak out over this series which includes a Catholic storyline? Will he be able to shoe horn in more Sly & Arnold references? The answers are YES & NO, but not necessarily in that order... PLUS! Top 3 Bad Babies in film history.

    Oct 9, 2024

    1h 23m
31. 97

    I SAW THE TV GLOW

    Is that TV glowing? Or is it more of a dull flicker? PLUS! Top 3 Spooky Screens in film history. And Tony takes us to the movies!

    Sep 21, 2024

    1h 14m
32. 96

    Where Have You Been?

    What? It wasn't us. Where have YOU been? The boys are back!

    Sep 12, 2024

    1h 09m
33. 95

    DREAM SCENARIO

    Is this Nick at his Cagiest? Plus: Top 3 nerds in film history!

    Apr 19, 2024

    1h 03m
34. 94

    CUJO with The Puppy Bowl Ref

    Our canine expert is BACK to analyze CUJO!

    Feb 13, 2024

    1h 19m
35. 93

    When Evil Lurks

    Is this one lurking around possibly being an all-time p4p film? Plus: Top 3 “We Don’t Wanna Go To THAT School” in film history.

    Feb 1, 2024

    1h 10m
36. 92

    The Last Voyage of the Demeter

    🎶The Dracula Boat…promises something for everyone 🎶

    Jan 19, 2024

    1h 07m
37. 91

    The 2024 TONY & MATTY AWARDS

    We look back at the best & worst of our 2023 reviews!

    Jan 12, 2024

    45m
38. 90

    Talk To Me

    Talk to us about Talk To Me. Plus our Top 3 Holiday Hi-jinks for Christmas!

    Dec 21, 2023

    1h 10m
39. 89

    No One Will Save You

    -The boys review this new alien film, but who really needs saving? The characters? All humans? The script? -Tony takes us back to the movies, this week: 1931. -PLUS our Top 3, this week: TOP 3 ALIEN KILLS in film history. Let’s go!

    Nov 30, 2023

    57m
40. 88

    Evil Dead Rise

    All rise! Plus: Top 3 BAD BOOKS in film history

    Nov 18, 2023

    1h 07m
41. 87

    P4P HALLOWEEN SPECIAL 2023

    Let’s get pumpkin all over ourselves!! Ew.

    Oct 31, 2023

    56m
42. 86

    Endangered Species

    Oh, wait. Maybe WE are the endangered species...? Or maybe not. We're deeply confused. This one's a doozy.

    Aug 30, 2023

    1h 22m
43. 85

    This One's For Mr. Arkin

    A special episode in which we pay homage to Tony's father & friend, the GREAT Alan Arkin. But as Mr. Arkin would want the boys get right to it and talk movies! In this case THE OMEN (1 &2). This one (and every one after this)...is for Tony's Dad. Thank you Alan Arkin.

    Aug 15, 2023

    1h 23m
44. 84

    M3GAN

    We have a doll. Her name is MeTHREEgan. Come play with us. PLUS! Top 3 Misspelled Titles In Film History.

    Jun 2, 2023

    1h 11m
45. 83

    The Birds

    We take on a classic film & director. THE BIRDS Plus: our TOP 3 High Pants in film/tv history! COME FLY WITH US!

    Apr 30, 2023

    1h 06m
46. 82

    POUND RIDGE & Top 3 Cigarette Moments In Film History

    Tony & Matty finally talk about their short POUND RIDGE. With a very special guest! We seriously recommend you watch their short (on our social media & Matty Blake's YouTube channel) before you listen! If you are a young budding artist or a salty 'ole pro or maybe just need some creative...

    Apr 13, 2023

    1h 27m
47. 81

    MONKEY SHINES w/ The Puppy Bowl Ref

    He's back! From Animal Planet's PUPPY BOWL it's the REF himself DAN SCHACHNER. We once again go to our animal correspondent to help us with MONKEY SHINES. Plus our TOP 3 Small Animal Attacks in film history. Let's P4P like monkeys!

    Mar 17, 2023

    1h 37m
48. 80

    PART 2: INVASION OF THE BODY SNATCHERS (1978) & Top 3 MALE PERMS

    Now we move from the 50's to the 70's in part DUEX of our Invasion Of The Body Snatchers 2 part special. Plus: The boys take on the current "shooting down UFO" craze. Then: Top 3 Male Perms in film history. YOU'RE NEXT!! (to enjoy a new P4P).

    Feb 24, 2023

    1h 22m
49. 79

    Invasion Of The Body Snatchers Pt 1 & Top 3 Syringe Stabs

    A special guest helps the boys open the PODS. INVASION OF THE BODY SNATCHERS (1956). Plus Top 3 Syringe Stabs in film history. This episode is coming for you!

    Feb 10, 2023

    1h 10m
50. 78

    SOMETHING IN THE DIRT & Top 3 Crappy Apartments

    We review the DIY sci fi, paranormal thriller SOMETHING IN THE DIRT. Matty knows all about searching for treasure in the dirt around the world...but have we found a gem here? Or should it remain buried? Let's get in this hot cramped apartment together and find out! And inspired by the cramped...

    Jan 19, 2023

    58m