All Episodes
Rated P For Paranormal — 127 episodes · page 1 of 2
DISCLOSURE DAY: The Veronica Corningstone Story
Home Is Where The Pod Is
Matty’s Got Seoul
THE TRAIL with Jake Robards
SPECIAL REPORT: The Missing Scientists
A BOY AND HIS DAWG
THE BEST THING WE SAW THIS WINTER
KPOP DEMON HUNTERS
This Island Earth
THEM!
Amelia Campbell from The Chair Company
TOGETHER
Deadly Friend
Mausoleum
2025 HALLOWEEN SPECIAL w/ PuppyBowl Ref Dan Schachner
REC
Things Herd & Scene
Phantasm
The Arrival
Apollo 18
THE MONKEY
Revelations
Presence
HOT FROSTY w/ the Puppy Bowl Ref
Poltergeist 2 & Top 3 Station Wagons
The Sentinel & Top 3 Contact Lensed Eyes
Nosferatu & Top 3 "Can This Be Over Now" Love Moments in film history
John Carpenter's HALLOWEEN & Top 3 Dumb Boyfriends
FRIDAY THE 13th & Top 3 Crazy Moms in Film
DREAMSCAPE & Top 3 Sweaty Presidents
30 Coins & T3 Bad Babies
I SAW THE TV GLOW
Where Have You Been?
DREAM SCENARIO
CUJO with The Puppy Bowl Ref
When Evil Lurks
The Last Voyage of the Demeter
The 2024 TONY & MATTY AWARDS
Talk To Me
No One Will Save You
Evil Dead Rise
P4P HALLOWEEN SPECIAL 2023
Endangered Species
This One's For Mr. Arkin
M3GAN
The Birds
POUND RIDGE & Top 3 Cigarette Moments In Film History
MONKEY SHINES w/ The Puppy Bowl Ref
PART 2: INVASION OF THE BODY SNATCHERS (1978) & Top 3 MALE PERMS
Invasion Of The Body Snatchers Pt 1 & Top 3 Syringe Stabs
SOMETHING IN THE DIRT & Top 3 Crappy Apartments
A Christmas Horror Story & The TONY & MATTY AWARDS!
The Secret Of Skinwalker Ranch
PREY
P4P Halloween Special: A NIGHTMARE ON ELM STREET
The POWER & Top 3 Nurses
The Wretched & Top RoadKill Moments
NOPE & ET's Earth Mama
THE GATE & T3 Holes in Film
Stranger Things 4
SPLASH & Top 3 Interspecies Relationships
THE DEEP HOUSE & T3 Underwater Scenes Ever
CARRIE: A Prom Porking
MONSTRUM & THE PUPPY BOWL REF
IN THE EARTH & Top 3 Gruesome Foot Injuries
AMITYVILLE HORROR & Top 3 DADS IN UNDERPANTS
FROM BEYOND & Top 3 Shoulder Pads in Film History
ARCHIVE 81 & Top 3 First Person Camera Moments In History
THE SHINING & Top 3 Baseball Bats In Film History
ALIENS AT THE PENTAGON & TOP 3 JACKETS IN FILM HISTORY
The 8th Night & Top 3 Creepy Smiles
Abbott & Costello Meet Frankenstein & Top SLAPS In History
ATTACK THE BLOCK & Top 3 Arm Yourself Moments
WENDIGO & The Top 3 Creepy Locals
PET SEMATARY & THE PUPPY BOWL REF
ALIEN and the Matty & Tony Awards!
END OF DAYS: The Arnold Argument
GhostBusters 2: We Feel Slimey
The GINGERDEAD MAN: This Cookie Didn't Crumble
ELVES: Why Are You Touching That?
SENDER: Darling You Sender Me, Honest You Do
The FRIGHTENERS: Matty Thinks Michael J Is A FOX
FIRESTARTER: "We Didn't Like The Fire" w/ special guest Brian Cano
PATRICK: "Shoulda Stayed In Bed"
DEAD ZONE: "Dead Man WALKEN'
Halloween Kills: MEH-chael Myers
Exorcist III: "You Had Us At Fabio"
The Exorcist 2 "Yo, Regan. I Did It!"
THE EXORCIST: Pazuzu’s Petals
THE THING: 2 Outta 3 Ain’t Bad
POLTERGEIST: Puppy Dog Tales
AN AMERICAN WEREWOLF IN LONDON: Wouldn’t You Want To Be A Werewolf Too?
SEPARATION: Waster Of Puppets
BRAND NEW CHERRY FLAVOR: Cat Fight!
EXTRA ORDINARY: Is This Will’s Forte?
THE TOMORROW WAR: Pratt Fall
BLACK SUMMER: Netflix & Kill
THE WIND: Everyone Knows It’s Windy
BONUS EPISODE: Don’t Call It A Comeback
DARK SKIES: We Believe In Keri Tales