All Episodes
Everything But The Cats — 129 episodes
Who is the better liar? Two Truths and a Lie
Premier League Preview: Five Fans, Zero Objectivity
The Long Hunt Case #001: Barrow's Crossing (part 3)
History's Strangest Outbreak: The Dancing Plague
The Long Hunt Case #001: Barrow's Crossing (Part 2)
The Greatest Soccer Match of All Time
The Cadaver Synod: When a Dead Pope Went on Trial
The Long Hunt Case #001: Barrow's Crossing (part 1)
The Hunt Begins: Monster of the Week Session 0
Our Official World Cup 2026 Predictions
Playing Honey Heist with Nick
Premier League Final Verdict - 25/26 Season Review
The Serpent, The Dragon, and The Red Pitchfork Guy
The Surprising History of the High Five
Tape Con, Movie Tropes, and the Lovely 90s with Nathan Hurley of Fox Royale
A Different View on Alcoholism
Fatherly advice from a fatherly...DJ
Dylan Borczak Interview: Soccer, Faith, and Starbucks Coffee
Interview with a (fake) Paranormal Investigator
Moral Kombat: (Mostly) Silly Debates and Celebrations
Poorly Explaining Naruto from Memory (Part 1)
2026 Drafts: Cult Leaders, Superpowers, and More!
Answering Relationship Question on Reddit with Garrett
The Great Maple Syrup Heist of 2012
How Not to Rob a Bank: Vincent Gepson
Answering Reddit's Most Pressing Questions
Playoff Predictions, Football for Dummies, and Drew Carey
The Cradle Series from Memory
Triangle Agency in Starlight Glen Part 2!
Behind the Curtain: Looking Back and Guessing Forward for 100 Episodes
Anomaly Detected in Starlight Glen: Triangle Agency Christmas Special (Part 1)
A Brief History of Eggnog
Laughter, Tears, and Growth in 2025
Fall Shenanigans, Mad Libs, and Autumnal Trivia
The Doomsday Method: A Mathematician's Party Trick
The Rapid Classification System (In our own words)
Christian Nationalism, Biblical Generosity, and Navigating Culture with TheNerdyChristian
Nouve Lune: The Mystery of the Drowned King -- Episode 2
Nouve Lune: The Mystery of the Drowned King -- Episode 1
Nouve Lune: Monster of the Week Session 0
From Samhain Sprites to Pumpkin Spice: How Pumpkins Became Synonymous with Fall
Guess The Guest: Part 2!
The Mysterious Case of the Bell Witch
Creatures Unseen: The Loch Ness Monster
The Hide and Seek World Champ: Bigfoot
Beebe's Untouchable Bathysphere Fish
Ministry, Theology, and Catching Up with Al Pal
The 1969 Berkshire UFO Incident
Campfire Stories with Jacob and Evan
Creatures Unseen: The Beast of Gevaudan
Creatures Unseen: The Kelly-Hopkinsville Encounter
Creatures Unseen: The Enfield Monster
Creatures Unseen: The Hauntings of the Stanley Hotel
Book Club: Until Unity by Francis Chan -- Conclusion
Creatures Unseen: The Jersey (Leeds) Devil
Book Club: Until Unity by Francis Chan--Chapter 8
Spicy Bryce: Friend, Printer of Things Three Dimensional, and Gamer Extraordinaire
Interview with Levi Qualls: Author, Father, and Pokemon Master
Book Club: Until Unity by Francis Chan--Chapter 7
The Great Emu War: Australia's Greatest Defeat
Book Club: Until Unity by Francis Chan -- Chapter 6
New Music and the Return of ANCONA
Book Club: Until Unity by Francis Chan--Chapter 5
Football, Brazil, and Trusting the Process: Interview with De'Anta Sipp
Book Club: Until Unity by Francis Chan--Chapter 4
Mothman: The Terror of the Skies
Book Club: Until Unity by Francis Chan--Chapter 3
The Gombe Chimpanzee War and Jane Goodall
Book Club: Until Unity by Francis Chan--Chapter 2
Best Movie Tournament Bracket w/ Adam Ward
Book Club: Until Unity by Francis Chan - Chapter 1
The Royale Cinema Lounge, Fox Royale, and Kevin Spacey with Nathan Hurley
Book Club: Until Unity by Francis Chan--Introduction
How Big is my Baby?
Return to Starlight Glen: Saving Christmas Part 2
Return to Starlight Glen: Saving Christmas Part 1
How the Bells Got Their Jingle
Christmas Gift Guide 2024
Books, Movies, Laughter, and Tears: Our Year in Review
Underrated Movies w/ Thomas of The Joy Schtick Show
Aerial Mysteries: STENDEC and Flight 19
Operation Paul Bunyan: Avoiding WWIII
The Horrors of Leif's Harbor: Part 2
The Horrors of Leif's Harbor: Part 1
DJ's (mom's) Scary Stories
Crappy Urban Legends w/ Mike and Brittany from the Oh Crap Podcast
Best Friend vs Wife: Who knows DJ best?
Three Movies and the True Stories Behind Them
How Not to do a Canoe Trip
Mail Bag Q&A Part 2
Everything You Need to Know About Hockey (And a draft)
Church Camp Stories
The trolley problem, good food, and living in China with Hayden VanDorien
Questions You Should Ask on a First Date
MLB 2024 Logo Tier List
Emperor Norton the First
Bugs as Weapons: Operations Big Itch, Big Buzz, and Dropkick
Mail Bag Q&A (Part 1)
Guess the Guest!
The Adam Ward Experience
Preparing DJ for Fatherhood
To the Landlord: A Creepypasta
Two Tails That Wagged as One
Horses: An evolutionary NightMare
Baby Archives: La Remontada
Living in Light of the Resurrection
The Baby Archives: Uruguayan Air Force Flight 571
Super Fight! W/ Caleb and Jacob
Baby Archives: The Tenerife Airport Disaster
Gage's Birthday Special!
Baby Archives: The Tunguska Event
The Ghost Ship (with the...Least Ship?)
We Predict The Super Bowl
Tax Evasion, Christmas Movies, and Fox Royale with Nathan Hurley
Interview with ANCONA: Music, Italy, and the Iowa state fair
The Raccoon Bear
Two Truths and a Lie
DJ's Birthday Special!
New Year's Eve Special!
Christmas Special: Starlight Glen Part 2
Christmas Special: Starlight Glen Part 1
Christmas Debates
Christmas Gift Ideas!
Thanksgiving Special: Our Year in Review
Our Favorite Video Games (So Far)
Draft Day Special (We know it's late)
Jordan Peele From Memory
Halloween Special: (un)Solved Mysteries Part 2
Halloween Special: (un)Solved Mysteries Part 1