All Episodes
Middle-Aged and Mediocre — 163 episodes
The True(ish) Story of Alonzo Weed - The 4 ft Tall Vagabond Who Became Mayor of a Small Town in Ohio
6 States That Tried To Break Up With the USA and Blind Ranking Adam Sandler and Childhood Sports Movies
Honcho and The Dude's WrestleMania 41 Preview
Raffaele Minichiello and the World's Longest and Most Spectacular Hijacking
The Hilariously Disastrous Russian Naval Failure Known as the Baltic Fleet
Ten Cent Beer Night In Cleveland
The True Story That Inspired "The Orphan" Movie and What Did Joel Do to RAW GM Adam Pearce (Plus Our Week 4 NFL Picks!)
How Reincarnation Solved a Murder: The Story of Titu Singh
The Church of the Firstborn's Doomsday Cult
Ranking the Ghostface Killers from Scream 1 through 3
Middle-Aged and Mediocre - Hot Dog Heroes
Tom Green Dreams
More Middle-Aged... More Mediocre... We're Back!
The Eastburn Family Murders
May the Fourth Be With You... and You and You... Not You
Solar Eclipse of Our Cold Dead Hearts
WrestleMania 40 Episode!
The Curiosities of The Curious Case of Natalia Grace *SPOILERS*
The Disappearance of Chase Massner
Middle-Aged and Mediocre's Super Bowl Preview
What's Up With the 3 Frozen Bodies Found in a Kansas City Man's Backyard?
Middle-Aged and Mediocre Presents The NFL Playoffs Divisional Round Preview Show
Middle-Aged and Mediocre Presents The Super Wild Card Weekend Preview Show
Susan Monica and Her Deadly Pig Farm
The Dexter Killer: Mark Twitchell Part Two
The Dexter Killer: Mark Twitchell Part One
Israel Keyes: The Devil and His Details
The Best of the Unsolved Mysteries Iceberg Part 5 (41-50)
The Best of the Unsolved Mysteries Iceberg Part 4 (31-40)
The Best of the Unsolved Mysteries Iceberg Part 3 (21-30)
The Best of the Unsolved Mysteries Iceberg Part 2 (11-20)
The Best of the Unsolved Mysteries Iceberg Part 1 (1-10)
The Sick and Twisted Night Taylor Schabusiness Decapitated Shad Thyrion
The Mystery of the Yuba City Boys
Middle-Aged and Concussed
Farce/Off: A Middle-Aged and Mediocre Reel Crime
Motivational Batman, Aliens, AITAH, The Denver Airport, and Summerslam 2023
Masters of the Universe - A Saga of Toys, Animated Show, and Film
Our Top 10 80s Movies Part Two: Cash's List
Our Top 10 80s Movies Part One: Joel's List
Count Dante - The World's Deadliest Man!
Notre Dame vs The Ku Klux Klan
The Haunting of Coraline Jones: A Reel Crime
The Santa Claus Bank Robbery
The Horrific & Hilarious Death of George Washington
The Life & Crimes of the Tylenol Man Part 2
The Life & Crimes of the Tylenol Man Part 1
The Great Egg War
Quick Update About the Show
The Kirtland Cult Killings
The Mysterious Murder of Natalie Bollinger
3 Bizarre Unsolved Mysteries
H.H. Holmes, I Resume: Part 2
The Cosmic Whiskey Hour On Ray Gun Radio Episode 1 - Jay Briscoe, The Bloodiest Match in Remix Pro, and How I Got Started in Professional Wrestling *NON-SPOTIFY EXCLUSIVE*
H.H. Holmes, I Presume: Part One
3 Twisted True Crime Tales
Fentanyl In Small-Town America and An Update On The Moscow Idaho Murders
24 News Stories That You Probably Missed in 2022 (Year In Review)
3 True Crimes That Should Be Turned Into Movies
5 Unsolved Murder Mysteries (Plus A Closer Look Into The Moscow Idaho Murders)
Middle-Aged and Mediocre Interviews TRICERATOPS
Benjamin Lay: The Woke Dwarf from the 18th Century / Stabbing Deaths of Four College Students in Moscow, Idaho
The Disciples of Destruction and Their New Hampshire Thrill Kill
5 Bizarre True Crime Stories
The New Jersey Suitcase Killer Melanie McGuire
PUMPKINHEAD (1988) Movie Review *SPOILERS*
The Lies and Murders of Chandler Halderson AND The Children of Thunder Murder Cult
HALLOWEEN III: SEASON OF THE WITCH (1982) Movie Review *SPOILERS*
HALLOWEEN ENDS (2022) Movie Review *SPOILERS*
YOU'RE NEXT (2013) Movie Review *SPOILERS*
The Unsolved Murders of Don Henry and Kevin Ives
PEARL Is A Star In Our Eyes (Movie Review *SPOILERS* Plus Clowns, Cannibals, and Dating Advice)
The Mystery of 312 Riverside Drive in NYC and BARBARIAN (2022) Movie Review ***SPOILERS***
NOPE (2022) and The Black Phone Reviews (2022) *SPOILERS*
Blood Fest (2018) Movie Review and More
Middle-Aged and Mediocre Reviews 1BR (Plus Vince McMahon Retires, Interacting with Professional Wrestlers, Ric Flair's Last Match, and Bar Fights)
Middle-Aged and Mediocre Reviews Satanic Panic (Plus Breaking Bad, Better Call Saul, Black Bird, new hats, Wendy's Goes Emo, Taco Bell, Chick-Fil-A Breaks Labor Laws, and Earth is Losing Time!)
Revealer (2022) Movie Review and More
DOLLAR TREE DAY! - Seagull (2019) Movie Review: Worst Movie Equals Our Worst Episode
Dashcam (2021) and X (2022) Movie Reviews (SPOILERS)
Two Farleys Lookin for a Spade
DOLLAR TREE DAY! - Everfall Movie Review (A Figure Skating Ghost Story... Maybe)
The Grim Murder of Becky Watts
Amish Homicide: The Edward Gingerich Story Part Two
Amish Homicide: The Edward Gingerich Story Part One and a Big USFL Show
From Riches to Robberies: The Story of Steve Carroll
REEL CRIMES - Spree Killer Kurt Kunkle
The Murder of Rachel Burkheimer
Katherine Mary Knight: Cannibal Housewife
Ray and Faye Copeland: America’s Oldest Couple On Death Row
We Were Brady'd!!! (aka The Royal Jumble)
Hardbody Harrison - Professional Wrestler Turned Sex Trafficker
The Villisca Axe Murders
REEL CRIMES - Christmas Eve Terror on Parking Level 2
The Bizarre Disappearance of Bryce Laspisa and The Incredibly Cursed Town of Skidmore Missouri
The Unsolved Mystery of Paddy Moriarty
Doctor Satan - France's Most Prolific Murderer
The Man Who Killed Halloween - The Pixy Stix Killer
The Exorcisms of Latoya Ammons
REEL CRIMES - The Camp Crystal Lake Murders - Season 2 Episode 2
The Tragedy of The Children of God Sex Cult and Ricky Rodriguez
Middle-Aged and Mediocre Interviews The Mothman! *MAAM EXCLUSIVE*
It's-A 2 Million Dollar Mario! - SO MANY BEES - Texas Man Loses Deadly Snake But Apologizes So It's Fine - AND A TRUE CRIME STORY... Episode 60
Beefalo - Books - Ducks - Swinger Trailer Park - Dead Body - Snakes - Meth Addicted Trout - Death by Masturbation... Episode 59
New Marriage Rules - Eyebrow Crabs - Fun With Hookworms - Chili Dogs - Gator Toss... Episode 58
Statues Full of Corpses - Toilet Snakes - President Cicada - Million Dollar Mario - Drunk Survivor - Birds Aren't Real - Penishrinkage... Episode 57
Joel's Song - Peniskin - Vidya Games - Chairs - SO MUCH MORE... Episode 56
First Openly Gay NFL Player - Califlorida - 1 Star Review - TMZ Mad Libs - Money on Mars - Zero Percent Chance... Episode 55
Oceans - Sex on Mars - Street Light Interference - Shopping Cart Theory - Balls - Holes... Episode 54
Another Fun Episode! $100K McNuggets, Joel's New Chair, Ranking Kevin Smith Movies, and Our New Cult - Episode 53
The Third Wave Experiment - Episode 52
The Gainesville Ripper (The True Crime That Inspired 'Scream') - Episode 51
The Year of the Locust - Episode 50
Jameson Irish Cannibalism - Episode 49
Betrayal on The 7-11 Ranch: The Disappearance and Murder of Jake Millison - Episode 48
The Extraordinary Lives of Pauline Dakin - Episode 47
The Disappearance and Murder of Chelsea Bruck - Episode 46
The Trial of Paul Ray Varner, Jr - Episode 45
The Ripper Crew Terrorizes Chicago - Part 2 - Episode 44
The Ripper Crew Terrorizes Chicago - Part 1 - Episode 43
The Disappearance of Zebb Quinn - Episode 42
The Farmville Murders - Episode 41
Bayard Peakes Kills for Science and James Dale Ritchie Kills for a Bike - Episode 40
The Earthquake Killer and What Did Time Travel Have To Do With Anna Repkina's Death? - Episode 39
The Abduction of Betty and Barney Hill (The Zeta Reticuli Incident) - Episode 38
A Death at Rattlesnake Canyon - Episode 37
The Unexplained Death of Blair Adams - Episode 36
Santa's Slay (2005) AND Giveaway Contest Announcement - Middle-Aged and Mediocre Movie Review
Ernest Wholaver Jr: A Father's Christmas Eve Massacre - Episode 35
The Carnation Murders (Christmas Eve - 2007) - Episode 34
The Year 2020 (Our 1 Year Anniversary Show) - Episode 33
Freaky (2020) - Middle-Aged and Mediocre Movie Review
Victor Licata: The Marihuana Maniac - Episode 32
No Holds Barred (1989) - Middle-Aged and Mediocre Movie Review
A Fun Episode! Does Canada Exist? What Happens When You Die? What's Florida Man Up To? - Episode 31
Hack-O-Lantern (1988) - Middle-Aged and Mediocre Movie Review
Mothman (2010 Made-for-TV Movie) - Middle-Aged and Mediocre Movie Review
The Mothman of Point Pleasant, WV - Episode 29
Marvin Heemeyer and His Killdozer - Episode 28
The Unsolved Death of Thomas Brown - Episode 27
America's First Ghost - Nelly Butler - Episode 26
The Greenbrier Ghost and The Legend of Wizard Clip (West Virginia Ghost Stories) - Episode 25
The Terrifying Reality of Sleep Paralysis - Episode 23
The Mystery of the Lead Masks - Episode 22
Hon-Ming Chen and the True Way Cult - Episode 21
The Battle of Athens Tennessee (An American History Episode) - Episode 19
The Corpsewood Manor Murders - Episode 18
Joel's Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Day: Meet Your Hosts - 1st Edition - Episode 17
Roch Thériault and the Ant Hill Kids Cult - Episode 16
The Tamam Shud Case (aka The Mystery of the Somertan Man) - Episode 14
The Keddie Cabin Murders - Episode 13
The Disappearance of the Sodder Children - Episode 12
The Jetpack Murder Part 2 - Episode 11
The Jetpack Murder Part 1 - Episode 10
Meat Cute: The Armin Meiwes Cannibal Story - Episode 9
The Cleveland Torso Murders Part 2 - Episode 8
The Cleveland Torso Murders Part 1 - Episode 7
Mamie Thurman and the 22 Mountain Murder - Episode 6
Who Put Bella in the Wytch Elm? - Episode 5
Hall Mills Murders (aka It's a Pig Woman's World and We're Just Livin' In It) - Episode 4
Emus Die Hard (The Great Emu War) - Episode 3
The Quiet Dell Murders in Clarksburg, WV - Episode 2
The Hinterkaifeck Murders - March 31, 1922 - Episode 1