All Episodes
Middle-Aged and Mediocre — 167 episodes · page 1 of 2
MAAM Commentary Buddies #002: Friday the 13th Part VI: Jason Lives — Commentary Track
EMAAM Commentary Buddies #001: Child’s Play 3 — Commentary Track
ENetflix... Explain Yourself. | Matchbox Movies, Resident Evil & Guessflix!
EThe True(ish) Story of Alonzo Weed - The 4 ft Tall Vagabond Who Became Mayor of a Small Town in Ohio
E6 States That Tried To Break Up With the USA and Blind Ranking Adam Sandler and Childhood Sports Movies
EHoncho and The Dude's WrestleMania 41 Preview
ERaffaele Minichiello and the World's Longest and Most Spectacular Hijacking
EThe Hilariously Disastrous Russian Naval Failure Known as the Baltic Fleet
ETen Cent Beer Night In Cleveland
EThe True Story That Inspired "The Orphan" Movie and What Did Joel Do to RAW GM Adam Pearce (Plus Our Week 4 NFL Picks!)
EHow Reincarnation Solved a Murder: The Story of Titu Singh
EThe Church of the Firstborn's Doomsday Cult
ERanking the Ghostface Killers from Scream 1 through 3
EMiddle-Aged and Mediocre - Hot Dog Heroes
ETom Green Dreams
EMore Middle-Aged... More Mediocre... We're Back!
EThe Eastburn Family Murders
EMay the Fourth Be With You... and You and You... Not You
ESolar Eclipse of Our Cold Dead Hearts
EWrestleMania 40 Episode!
EThe Curiosities of The Curious Case of Natalia Grace *SPOILERS*
EThe Disappearance of Chase Massner
EMiddle-Aged and Mediocre's Super Bowl Preview
EWhat's Up With the 3 Frozen Bodies Found in a Kansas City Man's Backyard?
EMiddle-Aged and Mediocre Presents The NFL Playoffs Divisional Round Preview Show
EMiddle-Aged and Mediocre Presents The Super Wild Card Weekend Preview Show
ESusan Monica and Her Deadly Pig Farm
EThe Dexter Killer: Mark Twitchell Part Two
EThe Dexter Killer: Mark Twitchell Part One
EIsrael Keyes: The Devil and His Details
EThe Best of the Unsolved Mysteries Iceberg Part 5 (41-50)
EThe Best of the Unsolved Mysteries Iceberg Part 4 (31-40)
EThe Best of the Unsolved Mysteries Iceberg Part 3 (21-30)
EThe Best of the Unsolved Mysteries Iceberg Part 2 (11-20)
EThe Best of the Unsolved Mysteries Iceberg Part 1 (1-10)
EThe Sick and Twisted Night Taylor Schabusiness Decapitated Shad Thyrion
EThe Mystery of the Yuba City Boys
EMiddle-Aged and Concussed
EFarce/Off: A Middle-Aged and Mediocre Reel Crime
EMotivational Batman, Aliens, AITAH, The Denver Airport, and Summerslam 2023
EMasters of the Universe - A Saga of Toys, Animated Show, and Film
EOur Top 10 80s Movies Part Two: Cash's List
EOur Top 10 80s Movies Part One: Joel's List
ECount Dante - The World's Deadliest Man!
ENotre Dame vs The Ku Klux Klan
EThe Haunting of Coraline Jones: A Reel Crime
The Santa Claus Bank Robbery
EThe Horrific & Hilarious Death of George Washington
EThe Life & Crimes of the Tylenol Man Part 2
EThe Life & Crimes of the Tylenol Man Part 1
EThe Great Egg War
Quick Update About the Show
EThe Kirtland Cult Killings
EThe Mysterious Murder of Natalie Bollinger
E3 Bizarre Unsolved Mysteries
EH.H. Holmes, I Resume: Part 2
EThe Cosmic Whiskey Hour On Ray Gun Radio Episode 1 - Jay Briscoe, The Bloodiest Match in Remix Pro, and How I Got Started in Professional Wrestling *NON-SPOTIFY EXCLUSIVE*
EH.H. Holmes, I Presume: Part One
E3 Twisted True Crime Tales
EFentanyl In Small-Town America and An Update On The Moscow Idaho Murders
E24 News Stories That You Probably Missed in 2022 (Year In Review)
E3 True Crimes That Should Be Turned Into Movies
E5 Unsolved Murder Mysteries (Plus A Closer Look Into The Moscow Idaho Murders)
EMiddle-Aged and Mediocre Interviews TRICERATOPS
EBenjamin Lay: The Woke Dwarf from the 18th Century / Stabbing Deaths of Four College Students in Moscow, Idaho
EThe Disciples of Destruction and Their New Hampshire Thrill Kill
E5 Bizarre True Crime Stories
EThe New Jersey Suitcase Killer Melanie McGuire
EPUMPKINHEAD (1988) Movie Review *SPOILERS*
EThe Lies and Murders of Chandler Halderson AND The Children of Thunder Murder Cult
EHALLOWEEN III: SEASON OF THE WITCH (1982) Movie Review *SPOILERS*
EHALLOWEEN ENDS (2022) Movie Review *SPOILERS*
EYOU'RE NEXT (2013) Movie Review *SPOILERS*
EThe Unsolved Murders of Don Henry and Kevin Ives
EPEARL Is A Star In Our Eyes (Movie Review *SPOILERS* Plus Clowns, Cannibals, and Dating Advice)
EThe Mystery of 312 Riverside Drive in NYC and BARBARIAN (2022) Movie Review ***SPOILERS***
ENOPE (2022) and The Black Phone Reviews (2022) *SPOILERS*
EBlood Fest (2018) Movie Review and More
EMiddle-Aged and Mediocre Reviews 1BR (Plus Vince McMahon Retires, Interacting with Professional Wrestlers, Ric Flair's Last Match, and Bar Fights)
EMiddle-Aged and Mediocre Reviews Satanic Panic (Plus Breaking Bad, Better Call Saul, Black Bird, new hats, Wendy's Goes Emo, Taco Bell, Chick-Fil-A Breaks Labor Laws, and Earth is Losing Time!)
ERevealer (2022) Movie Review and More
EDOLLAR TREE DAY! - Seagull (2019) Movie Review: Worst Movie Equals Our Worst Episode
EDashcam (2021) and X (2022) Movie Reviews (SPOILERS)
ETwo Farleys Lookin for a Spade
EDOLLAR TREE DAY! - Everfall Movie Review (A Figure Skating Ghost Story... Maybe)
EThe Grim Murder of Becky Watts
EAmish Homicide: The Edward Gingerich Story Part Two
EAmish Homicide: The Edward Gingerich Story Part One and a Big USFL Show
EFrom Riches to Robberies: The Story of Steve Carroll
EREEL CRIMES - Spree Killer Kurt Kunkle
EThe Murder of Rachel Burkheimer
EKatherine Mary Knight: Cannibal Housewife
ERay and Faye Copeland: America’s Oldest Couple On Death Row
EWe Were Brady'd!!! (aka The Royal Jumble)
EHardbody Harrison - Professional Wrestler Turned Sex Trafficker
EThe Villisca Axe Murders
EREEL CRIMES - Christmas Eve Terror on Parking Level 2
EThe Bizarre Disappearance of Bryce Laspisa and The Incredibly Cursed Town of Skidmore Missouri
EThe Unsolved Mystery of Paddy Moriarty
EDoctor Satan - France's Most Prolific Murderer
E