All episodes

The Man Who Killed Halloween - The Pixy Stix Killer

The Exorcisms of Latoya Ammons

REEL CRIMES - The Camp Crystal Lake Murders - Season 2 Episode 2

The Tragedy of The Children of God Sex Cult and Ricky Rodriguez

Middle-Aged and Mediocre Interviews The Mothman! *MAAM EXCLUSIVE*

It's-A 2 Million Dollar Mario! - SO MANY BEES - Texas Man Loses Deadly Snake But Apologizes So It's Fine - AND A TRUE CRIME STORY... Episode 60

Beefalo - Books - Ducks - Swinger Trailer Park - Dead Body - Snakes - Meth Addicted Trout - Death by Masturbation... Episode 59

New Marriage Rules - Eyebrow Crabs - Fun With Hookworms - Chili Dogs - Gator Toss... Episode 58

Statues Full of Corpses - Toilet Snakes - President Cicada - Million Dollar Mario - Drunk Survivor - Birds Aren't Real - Penishrinkage... Episode 57

Joel's Song - Peniskin - Vidya Games - Chairs - SO MUCH MORE... Episode 56

First Openly Gay NFL Player - Califlorida - 1 Star Review - TMZ Mad Libs - Money on Mars - Zero Percent Chance... Episode 55

Oceans - Sex on Mars - Street Light Interference - Shopping Cart Theory - Balls - Holes... Episode 54

Another Fun Episode! $100K McNuggets, Joel's New Chair, Ranking Kevin Smith Movies, and Our New Cult - Episode 53

The Third Wave Experiment - Episode 52

The Gainesville Ripper (The True Crime That Inspired 'Scream') - Episode 51

The Year of the Locust - Episode 50

Jameson Irish Cannibalism - Episode 49

Betrayal on The 7-11 Ranch: The Disappearance and Murder of Jake Millison - Episode 48

The Extraordinary Lives of Pauline Dakin - Episode 47

The Disappearance and Murder of Chelsea Bruck - Episode 46

The Trial of Paul Ray Varner, Jr - Episode 45

The Ripper Crew Terrorizes Chicago - Part 2 - Episode 44

The Ripper Crew Terrorizes Chicago - Part 1 - Episode 43

The Disappearance of Zebb Quinn - Episode 42

The Farmville Murders - Episode 41

Bayard Peakes Kills for Science and James Dale Ritchie Kills for a Bike - Episode 40

The Earthquake Killer and What Did Time Travel Have To Do With Anna Repkina's Death? - Episode 39

The Abduction of Betty and Barney Hill (The Zeta Reticuli Incident) - Episode 38

A Death at Rattlesnake Canyon - Episode 37

The Unexplained Death of Blair Adams - Episode 36

Santa's Slay (2005) AND Giveaway Contest Announcement - Middle-Aged and Mediocre Movie Review

Ernest Wholaver Jr: A Father's Christmas Eve Massacre - Episode 35

The Carnation Murders (Christmas Eve - 2007) - Episode 34

The Year 2020 (Our 1 Year Anniversary Show) - Episode 33

Freaky (2020) - Middle-Aged and Mediocre Movie Review

Victor Licata: The Marihuana Maniac - Episode 32

No Holds Barred (1989) - Middle-Aged and Mediocre Movie Review

A Fun Episode! Does Canada Exist? What Happens When You Die? What's Florida Man Up To? - Episode 31

Hack-O-Lantern (1988) - Middle-Aged and Mediocre Movie Review

Mothman (2010 Made-for-TV Movie) - Middle-Aged and Mediocre Movie Review

The Mothman of Point Pleasant, WV - Episode 29

Welcome to Sudden Death (2020) - Middle-Aged and Mediocre Movie Review

Marvin Heemeyer and His Killdozer - Episode 28

The Unsolved Death of Thomas Brown - Episode 27

America's First Ghost - Nelly Butler - Episode 26

The Greenbrier Ghost and The Legend of Wizard Clip (West Virginia Ghost Stories) - Episode 25

The Mystery of the Circleville Letters - Episode 24

The Terrifying Reality of Sleep Paralysis - Episode 23

The Mystery of the Lead Masks - Episode 22

Hon-Ming Chen and the True Way Cult - Episode 21

The Wide Awakes (An American History Episode) - Episode 20

The Battle of Athens Tennessee (An American History Episode) - Episode 19

The Corpsewood Manor Murders - Episode 18

Joel's Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Day: Meet Your Hosts - 1st Edition - Episode 17

Roch Thériault and the Ant Hill Kids Cult - Episode 16

Who Shot Ken Rex McElroy and Why Didn't They Do It Sooner? - Episode 15

The Tamam Shud Case (aka The Mystery of the Somertan Man) - Episode 14

The Keddie Cabin Murders - Episode 13

The Disappearance of the Sodder Children - Episode 12

The Jetpack Murder Part 2 - Episode 11

The Jetpack Murder Part 1 - Episode 10

Meat Cute: The Armin Meiwes Cannibal Story - Episode 9

The Cleveland Torso Murders Part 2 - Episode 8

The Cleveland Torso Murders Part 1 - Episode 7

Mamie Thurman and the 22 Mountain Murder - Episode 6

Who Put Bella in the Wytch Elm? - Episode 5

Hall Mills Murders (aka It's a Pig Woman's World and We're Just Livin' In It) - Episode 4

Emus Die Hard (The Great Emu War) - Episode 3

The Quiet Dell Murders in Clarksburg, WV - Episode 2

The Hinterkaifeck Murders - March 31, 1922 - Episode 1