All episodes
Karmen Smith & Lottie Spencer | 49
Lauren Giddings | 48
Christina Parcell (The Rose Petal Murder) | 47
Hannah Wilson | 46
Camille Arfmann | 45
Your Creepy Stories 1 | 44
Joleen Cummings | 43
Kay Parsons | 42
Ruth Finley | 41
Sparkle Rai | 40
Sydney Loofe | 39
The Villemin Family | 38
The Unspeakable Hosts | 37
Nicole van den Hurk | 36
Hannah Cornelius & Cheslin Marsh | 35
Ashley Pond & Miranda Gaddis | 34
Bonus Episode: Idaho Affidavit!! | 33
Ricky Cowles Jr. | 32
Meghan Landowski | 31
Eastburn Family Murders | 30
Adriane Insogna, Leslie Mazzara & Lauren Meanza | 29
Jessie Blodgett | 28
Shannon Green, Dewayne Bell & Angie Dickens | 27
Ryan Waller and Heather Quan | 26
Alex Skeel and Jordan Worth | 25
Josephine Cook | 24
Nikki VanderHeyden | 23
Ellen Halbert | 22
Pam Butler & Marta Rodriguez | 21
Brittani Marcell | 20
John Broyhill and Jamie & Nation Hahn | 19
Teresita Basa | 18
Jessica Dishon | 17
Cindy James | 16
Ken and Barbie Killers | 15
Nicholas Barclay | 14
Shelley Nance | 13
John List | 12
Colleen Stan | 11
Donnah Winger | 10
Goose Green Stabbing | 9
Talhotblond | 8
Nyleen Marshall | 7
Delimar Vera | 6
Michelle Hadley & Angela Diaz | 5
The Andrews Family | 4
Charlie & Teri Brandt and Michelle Jones | 3
Frank Floyd | 2
Carolynne Watson & Julian Buchwald | 1
TRAILER