All episodes
Terry Caffey | 149
ECasey White | 148
EAustin Lee Edwards | 147
EBilly Payne and Billie Jean Hayworth | 146
EDiane Zamora and David Graham | 145
EKen Rex McElroy | 144
ETaylor Parker | 143
EKalinka Bamberski | 142
EMatthew Heikkila | 141
EBrenda Heist | 140
EMary Day | 139
EDorothy Donovan | 138
EPaul Lambert | 137
EClayton Daniels | 136
EPeter & Joan Porco | 135
EJames Duncan | 134
ETeri Jendusa Nicolai | 133
ENancy Pfister | 132
EThe Coleman Family Murders | 131
EEduardo & Jayne Valseca | 130
EMargie Danielsen | 129
EAlison Botha | 128
EBill Stout | 127
EThe Hollywood Ripper | 126
EAdam Lane | 125
EHalloween: Your Scary Stories | 124
EJennifer Still | 123
EChelsea Bruck | 122
ECreepy Halloween Stories | 121
EThrowback to Episode 29: The Napa Murders
EThe Harrison Family | 119
EMissoula Mauler | 118
EBrenda Sue Schaefer | 117
EAmber Smith | 116
ECorey Wieneke | 115
EAshley Benson | 114
EDustin Wehde | 113
ESandra Hemme | 112
EElizabeth Shoaf | 111
ELarry McNabney | 110
EThe Tweed Creeper | 109
EGinger Rios | 108
EKenzie Houk | 107
EClaire Holland | 106
Barry Titus | 105
EScary Reddit Stories | 104
Glenn and Betty Sandler | 103
EThe Hargan's | 102
EThe Kurim Case | 101
EBaffling Stories | 100
EDiane Newton King | 99
EMissy Avila | 98
EKit Martin | 97
EJohn Darwin | 96
ERay Wright | 95
EAshley Reeves | 94
ELatrese Curtis | 93
EThabo Bester | 92
EStacie and Kristie Reed | 91
EBob and Kay Swartz | 90
Angie Dodge | 89
ENikki Whitehead | 88
EYara Gambirasio | 87
ETanya Kach | 86
Susie Newsom Lynch & Fritz Klenner | 85
Jennifer Asbenson | 84
Jamie Faith | 83
Paul Fronczak | 82
Karen Gregory | 81
Stephen Morin | 80
Cari Farver | 79
Stephen & Diane Schap | 78
Nadja & Payton Medley and Mike Bullinger | 77
The Pillow Pyro | 76
Jesse Valencia | 75
Natalie Bollinger | 74
Christi Flynn | 73
Natasha Ryan | 72
Dana Laskowski | 71
Jennifer & Noura Jackson | 70
Sabrina Kouider and Sam Medouni | 69
Bart & Jennifer Corbin | 68
Natalee Holloway: Part 4 of 4 | 67
Natalee Holloway: Part 3 of 4 | 66
Natalee Holloway: Part 2 of 4 | 65
Natalee Holloway: Part 1 of 4 | 64
Lori Slesinski | 63
Dan & Donna Arnold | 62
Clark Rockefeller | 61
The Whitaker Family | 60
Linda Slaten | 59
Sam Herr & Julie Kibuishi | 58
Laurie Mckenna & Jeanine Grinsell | 57
Stacie Pannell | 56
Quinn Gray | 55
Judy Smith | 54
Nick Rossi | 53
Sonya Ivanoff | 52
Your Creepy Stories 2 | 51
Weepy Voice Killer | 50