All episodes
Strange Happenings in the Mountains of Washington State
r/BackwoodsCreepy; My Experience in Pisgah National Forest
r/Lets_Not_Meet; My Dog’s a Good Boy
r/Paranormal; My College Ouija Board Experience
r/TrueScaryStories; Another Garage Door Story | Walking at Night
r/TrueScaryStories; The Mystery Package Sender | Whose Foot Was That?
r/TrueScaryStories; Always Shut Your Garage Door | To the Man by the Shed
r/CreepyEncounters; I Met Someone Who Could Have Ended My Life without Knowing | Biology Tutor Stalker
r/TrueScaryStories; If You See Someone Waving You Down on a Desolate Highway, Don’t Stop
r/AskReddit; What’s the Scariest Thing that Science Has Proven Is Real?
r/Lets_Not_Meet; I Was Stalked for a Month and Had No Clue
r/CreepyEncounters; When a Gut Feeling Saves You from the Man Waiting for You in a Doorway
r/AskReddit; What Conspiracy Theory Do You Believe Is 100% True?
r/BackwoodsCreepy; Creepy Encounter in the South Carolina Swamps | Followed in the Woods
r/Lets_Not_Meet; Visiting an Abandoned Cottage Next to Mine. Didn’t Go So Well.
r/BackwoodsCreepy; There’s Something Weird about the Woods behind My House
r/CreepyEncounters; Creature in the Woods | Sleep Paralysis Turned Real
The Jonestown Massacre
r/TrueScaryStories; Missing from the Cabin in the Woods
r/UnsolvedMysteries; The Freeway Phantom
r/ConspiracyTheories; Ancient Giants Buried in the Mounds Across North America
r/CreepyEncounters; Let Me Tell You about the Button Man
Listener Story: New Orleans
r/CreepyEncounters; Is My Neighbor Stalking Me? | Sketchy Doordash Driver
Listener Story: Not So Imaginary Friend Part 2 | Something Weird about Their House
Listener Story: Not So Imaginary Friend
r/AskReddit; Scariest Things Morticians Experienced at Work
Listener Stories: Disentombing and Relocating | The Haunting on Hawthorn Avenue
r/TrueScaryStories; Creepy Cowboy | I’ve Only Told This to My Closest Friend | The Owl
The Murdaugh Murders
r/TrueScaryStories; Man Stalking My Sister in the Woods | The Work Stalker
r/UnresolvedMysteries; Criminal Jogger Pushes Woman into a Bus | 14 Year Old Boy Found After 20 Years
r/TrueScaryStories; Truck Stop Horror Part 2
r/TrueScaryStories; Truck Stop Horror
r/Lets_Not_Meet; Almost Kidnapped in Miami Because of Instagram | I Won’t Ever Volunteer in a Homeless Shelter Ever Again
r/AskReddit; What Were the Conspiracy Theorists Right About?
r/Lets_Not_Meet; The Crocks and Socks Stalker
r/UnresolvedMysteries; The English Sweating Sickness that Ravished 15th Century British Society | Detached Feet
r/Paranormal; Strangers in Woods Acting Strange
r/CreepyEncounters; The Man I Saw Through My Night Vision Scope
r/Paranormal; What Happened to You That Initially You Thought Was Paranormal, but in the End It Wasn’t?
r/ConspiracyTheories; Serial Killers Are Not Who We’ve Been Led to Believe | Hollow Earth
r/Lets_Not_Meet; Close Call, Pervert in My House | The Cat Tries to Warn Us
r/AskReddit; Have You Ever Been Scared to the Core of Your Soul?
Why I Still Lock All the Windows in My House | A Very Strange Child
r/AskReddit; What Unexplainable or Scary Event Happened to You in Your Own Home?
r/shortscarystories; AITA for Leaving My Fiance 2 Weeks Before Our Wedding | How Did He Know?
r/BackwoodsCreepy; Experience in George Washington National Forest. Still Not Sure What Happened
r/Lets_Not_Meet; To Whomever Was In My Car with Me Last Night | Stranger Danger | Followed Around Town
r/shortscarystories; Meet My Family
r/Lets_Not_Meet; Beware of the Children of the Neighborhoods | A Summer Camp Gave Us Nightmares
r/Horrorstories; Old Jack | They’re Here
r/TrueScaryStories; Finding a Closed Off Room in My Old House
r/TrueScaryStories; The Barber | I Was Followed
r/Lets_Not_Meet; He Tried to Come In and Clean Our Apartments
r/BackwoodsCreepy; Lake House Weekend
r/BackwoodsCreepy; Terrifying Day in Oklahoma Woods | The Jamison Family
r/Horrorstories; Do Not Open | Hikers of Reddit, What’s the Most Messed Up Thing You’ve Seen?
r/ParanormalEncounters; An Encounter with an Entity I Had When I Was 4 Years Old | Nearly Murdered by a Ghost
r/AskReddit; What’s the Scariest Encounter You Had with a Total Stranger?
r/UnresolvedMysteries; Karlie Gusé
r/UnresolvedMysteries; Lenny Dirickson
r/Lets_Not_Meet; Has Someone Been in My Home?
r/Lets_Not_Meet; Don’t Drive Straight Home Part 2
r/Lets_Not_Meet; Don’t Drive Straight Home
r/AskReddit; What Is the Scariest Encounter with a Person You’ve Ever Had?
r/Lets_Not_Meet; I Escaped a Fake Deliverer
r/UnresolvedMysteries; “If something happens to us, we were murdered”: Who Killed Kylen Schulte and Crystal Turner?
r/TrueScaryStories; He Might Actually Be Angry | The Red Woman | The Knocks
r/AskReddit; Campers of reddit, What Is the Scariest, Creepiest, Most Disturbing Thing That Has Happened to You in the Woods?
r/AskReddit; People of Reddit Who Work the Day Shift at a Non-Haunted Business, What’s Your Creepy Experience?
r/Lets_Not_Meet; The Window Creeper | Followed in the Woods
r/BackwoodsCreepy; Growing Up in the Appalachian Mountains | The Smiling Man
r/Lets_Not_Meet; The Laboratory in the Forest
r/AskReddit; What’s the Creepiest Thing You’ve Heard at Night?
r/MecThology; The Bell Witch from American Urban Legends | A Fetch | The Ghost of Bellamy Bridge
r/Glitch_in_the_Matrix; It Wasn’t Her… | r/CreepyEncounters; 3 Men Came Looking for Me at My House Today
r/NFL; What Is an NFL Conspiracy That You 100% Believe in or Is Plausible?
r/TrueScaryStories; Grandma on the Run | Never That Safe
r/TrueScaryStories; Apparition in My Friend’s Home | The Wendigo
r/AskReddit; Women Who Gave the Creepy Guy a Chance, How Did It Go?
r/AskReddit; What Conspiracy Theories Turned Out to Be True, but Most People Still Don’t Know about Them?
r/AskReddit; What Celebrity Conspiracy Theory Do You Absolutely, 100% Believe Is True
r/TrueScaryStories; I Ran into a Cult in the Woods 1.5 Miles from My House | I Think I Watched Myself Walk Home
r/Lets_Not_Meet; I Escaped an Intruder by “Playing Along”
r/Glitch_in_the_Matrix; I Saw Myself across a Parking Lot…
r/UnresolvedMysteries; The Curious Case of Mr. Gorgos | Hollywood Man Reincarnated | The Jetpack Guy Is Back
r/ConspiracyTheories; Olive Garden Is Limiting Their Endless Soup | Marylin Monroe and the Kennedys
r/TrueScaryStories; Dead Cafeteria Lady | The One Experience I Can’t Explain
r/TrueScaryStories; The Face in the Window of My Mom’s Basement | My Mother’s Stalker
r/Lets_Not_Meet; Hotel Ukraine Horror Story
r/Glitch_in_the_Matrix; The College Hook Up | My Husband’s Car Answered His Question
r/AskReddit; Redditors Who Have Had Someone Living in Your Home without You Knowing, What’s Your Story?
r/TrueScaryStories; Avoiding Abduction | Snapchat Creep
r/TrueScaryStories; The Bumpy Man
r/TrueScaryStories; Something’s Strange about My Boyfriend’s Dad | The Teacher
r/nonmurdermysteries; In 2004 the Entire Sri Lankan Handball Team Went Missing
Fan Story: Paranormal Experiences
Fan Story: My Sister Unintentionally Saved My Life
r/UnsolvedMysteries; The Disappearance of Asha Degree