All episodes
r/Glitch_in_the_Matrix; The Town That Shouldn’t Exist | I Died in a House Fire
Fan Story: The Man at the Pool | Robbery in a Rideshare
r/CreepyEncounters; Pay Attention to the Hairs on the Back of Your Neck | I Think My Grandmother Made a Profit off Me as a Kid
r/TrueScaryStories; A Body in the Corn Fields
r/Lets_Not_Meet; I Didn’t Realize Someone Was in My House | Open the Door, Please. Come Out
r/CreepyWikipedia; From Novel to Murder
r/TrueScaryStories; Never Babysitting Again | The Bellevue Haunting
r/AskReddit; What Is the Creepiest Historical Fact?
r/Lets_Not_Meet; I Got Followed in the Woods Twice by the Same Guy
r/CreepyEncounters; Unstable Psychiatrist Loses His Crap After I Ghost Him | Almost Kidnapped/Murdered in My Neighborhood While Walking
r/TrueScaryStories; My House Was Haunted | Road Trip Got Weird?
r/AskReddit; People Who Have Had a Stalker, How Did You Realize You Were Being Stalked and What Ended Up Happening?
r/AskReddit; What Is Perfectly Legal, but Creepy?
r/UnresolvedMysteries; Shawn Betz
r/AskReddit; What Conspiracy Theory Do You Fully Believe Is True?
r/Lets_Not_Meet; Coffee Shop Stalker
r/Paranormal; I Met My Son 10 Years Before He Was Born in a Dream | Husband and I Realize We’ve Seen It
r/ExploreWorld; The Sentinelese Island
r/Glitch_in_the_Matrix; Did the World End in 2012?
Ghost Ships
r/TrueScaryStories; Person Witnesses 47 Year Old Man with a Knife Attacking a 17 Year Old in a Sushi Place
r/TrueCrime; Out of All the Cases You Know about, What Is the Most Absurd Motive for the Crime That You’ve Heard Of?
r/Lets_Not_Meet; Behind You | Someone Tried to Abduct Me
r/BackwoodsCreepy; Paranormal Experience While Hunting in Alabama | The Woods
r/UnresolvedMysteries; Mummified Body Is Found Inside the Wall of the Long Shuddered Oakland Convention Center
Elizabeth Smart
r/Lets_Not_Meet; My Encounter with a Would Be Ax Murderer in the Middle of the Woods
r/Glitch_in_the_Matrix; I Swear My Little Sister in Law Is a Glitch in the Matrix | My Grandmother Made Cancer Disappear
r/Lets_Not_Meet; The Strange Woman Who Smiled at Me | Followed on the Sketchy Side of Town
The Disappearance of Joan Risch
r/TrueScaryStories; The Shadow Lady | The Man in the RV
r/AskReddit; What Is the Creepiest or Most Unexplained Thing That’s Happened to You That You Still Think About to This Day?
r/TrueScaryStories; I Found Someone Living Under My Couch | Skinwalker Father | Night on the Hill
r/UnresolvedMysteries; The Disappearance of Terrance Williams and Felipe Santos
Various Reddit Stories; Nearly Was Kidnapped | Stranger in Canada | Snowboarding Accident
Wikipedia; The Killing of JonBenét Ramsey
r/LetsNotMeet; My Brother and I Made Friends. I’m Grateful It Ended This Way
r/AskReddit; What’s the Creepiest/Most Unexplained Thing You’ve Seen in Broad Daylight?
r/Glitch_In_The_Matrix; I Fell Off a Cliff and When I Was Rescued My Entire Reality Was Different
r/Paranormal; Haunting of Bus 571
r/TrueScaryStories; The Reason I Don’t Go to My Aunt’s House | We Didn’t Leave a Voicemail
r/Paranormal; I Think I Witnessed a Cult Ritual | I Was a Skeptic Until I Spent a Few Nights in My Wife’s Childhood Home
Listener Story: The Hatch in the Ground
r/AskReddit; What Is the Creepiest Thing You’ve Seen in All the Places Outdoors?
The Hollow Man | Lured to the Abandoned House
r/AskReddit; What Are Some of the Creepiest Moments in Reddit History That People Seem to Have Forgotten?
r/ScaryStories; The Scariest Moment of My Life | True Paranormal Experience
r/UnresolvedMysteries; Daniel Reeves’ Case
r/TrueScaryStories; What Is a Situation You Were In as a Child That You Didn’t Realize the Potential Danger of Until You Looked Back on It
r/TrueScaryStories; Scary Road Trip Experiences
r/UnresolvedMysteries; What Cases Do You Have an Owl Theory on? | Norfolk Woman Sentenced to 20 Years in Girl’s Death
r/UnresolvedMysteries; What Cases Do You Have an Owl Theory on? | Jack Wheeler
r/aliens; What If Aliens Are Just Waiting for Us to Figure Out World Peace so We Can Join the Intergalactic Union? | Alien Abduction
r/TrueScaryStories; Unknown Man in the White Car | The Time My Grandpa Was Almost Murdered in a Mental Hospital
Listener Submissions: The Woman in My Brother’s Bedroom | r/Paranormal; I’ll Never Go Hunting Again
r/TrueScaryStories; The Boy Next Door That Died
r/CreepyEncounters; Never Doing Rideshare Again | Almost Abducted by a Serial Killer
r/SerialKillers; Ivan Milat
r/AskReddit; What’s the Most Terrifying Thing You’ve Experienced While Home Alone?
r/Conspiracy; The Mattress Firm Conspiracy
r/TrueScaryStories; Don’t Take Shortcuts
r/Glitch_in_the_Matrix; The Time I Ended Up in a Town That Doesn’t Exist
r/AskReddit; Hikers, Campers, Woodsmen, and the Like, What Are Your Scariest Experiences in Them There Woods? Part 2
r/LetsNotMeet; Home Invasion
r/AskReddit; Hikers, Campers, Woodsmen, and the Like, What Are Your Scariest Experiences in Them There Woods?
r/LetsNotMeet; A Stranger Calls
Thesportster.com: Olympic Conspiracies That May Be True Part 2
Thesportster.com: Olympic Conspiracies That May Be True
r/TrueScaryStories; Near Miss at a Bar | The Night Fairy Ghost | The Witches Tree
r/AskReddit; The Disappearance of Brandon Swanson
r/AskReddit; What High School Conspiracy Turned Out to Be True at Your School?
Fan Story: My Neighbor Stalked Me
r/TrueScaryStories; The California Fault Line | The Thing by the Window
r/AskReddit; Pilots and the Scariest Things They’ve Seen While Flying
r/TrueScaryStories; My Great Grandmother’s 19th Century Horror Story
r/AskReddit; What Are Some Dark Events in History Not Many People Know About?
r/AlienEncounters; Last Summer
r/LetsNotMeet; The Man That Lived in the Woods on My Property | The Staring Woman
r/AskReddit; What Was Your Creepy, Unexplained Experience as a Child?
r/TrueScaryStories; Last Summer I Worked as Beach Security | Gas Station Kidnapper
r/AskReddit; What Is a Supernatural Event That Happened in Your Life That just Cannot Be Explained
r/TrueScaryStories; Not All Fun and Games | The Thing at the Bottom of the Stairs
r/LetsNotMeet; Met a Creep Underwater While Scuba Diving and Being Unable to Communicate
Submission Story: I Still Don’t Know What I Saw That Night | Woke Up with Somebody in My Apartment
Submission Story: 4 Tales in the Hill Country
r/todayilearned; H. H. Holmes and the Murder Castle
r/AskReddit; What Is the Creepiest Encounter You Ever Had with Another Human Being?
r/TrueScaryStories; Who or What Was at My Door? | r/NoSleep; I Emailed My Son’s Christmas List to Santa and I didn’t Expect to Get a Respons
r/AskReddit; What Is the Scariest Thing You’ve Found on the Internet?
r/NoSleep; I Joined the Adult Table for the First Time This Year and Now I Wish I Never Grew Up Part 2
r/NoSleep; I Joined the Adult Table for the First Time This Year and Now I Wish I Never Grew Up
r/AskReddit; What’s the Scariest Real Thing on Our Earth?
Submitted Stories: The Keyhole Peeper | The Blue Striped Pajama Man
r/AskReddit; What Is the Creepiest, Explainable, Non-paranormal Story or Event that Happened to You? Part 3
r/NoSleep; I Played Hide and Seek with My Son and Found Something Terrifying
r/AskReddit; What Is the Creepiest, Explainable, Non-paranormal Story or Event that Happened to You? Part 2
r/AskReddit; What’s the Dumbest Conspiracy Theory You’ve Heard?
r/TrueScaryStories; My Friend Went Missing and We Didn’t Find Her in One Piece
r/TrueScaryStories; Abandoned Places Are No Joke
r/TrueScaryStories; House Ghost | The Creep in the Woods That Underestimated Me