All episodes

Ask Us Anything 2024 Part 2

Ask Us Anything 2024 (Part 1)

2024 True Crime Recap Live Stream

JonBenét Ramsey: 7 Details That STILL Don't Make Sense - #185

A new ghost is haunting John (unhinged and disturbing) - NMR #76

JonBenét Ramsey: John Narrates The 19-Page JonBenét Ramsey Police Report From 1997

The Wrong Ride Home - #184

The TikTok Tragedy (Flashback #139)

"Who Killed JonBenét Ramsey? (Reaction) - #183

Why does John's face look like that? - NMR #75

Who Killed Robert Wone? - #182

Aileen Wuornos (Flashback - #140)

We wrote poems about each other - NMR #74

The Mysterious End of Edgar Allen Poe - #181

The Pizza Bomber - #180

Haunted Houses and Our Favorite Halloween Candy - NMR #73

The Tragedy of Phil Hartman - #179

BONUS: Menendez Brothers Resentencing Press Conference Reaction

#178 - Fatal Love Triangle

NMR #72 - John Dreamed About Matt

#177 - "The Menendez Brothers" Netflix Documentary (Reaction)

Wake Up, It's Time To Die (Flashback)

#176 - The Staircase: Was It The Owl?

NMR #71 - Woke Up Screaming

#175 - The Mystery of the Natalie Wood

#174 - The Broomstick Murders

NMR #70 - Why Does Taking A Walk Cost One Hundred Dollars?

#173 - Her Best Friends Killed Her

#172 - "Face to Face with Scott Peterson" (Reaction)

NMR #69 - Andy's Wax Figure Is Too Real

#171 - The Cleveland Torso Murders

#170 - Horror In Knoxville

NMR #68 - John Reacts To Daryn's Bug Bites (Disturbing OMG)

#169 - Our Favorite Episodes: Which Case Wins The Gold?

#168 - Botched: The Bloody Dr. Brown

NMR #67 - Gold Medal on The Hobby Horse

#167 - The Starkweather Rampage

Hollywood Horror In NYC (Flashback)

#166 - The Pickton Pig Farm Massacres

#165 - The Truth About Crystal

NMR #66 - How Do We Make Friends!?

#164 - The Dixmoor Disaster

#163 - Beauty Queen Brutality

NMR #65 - Spiders Need To Stop

The Hidden Gunshot Wound (Flashback)

The Bleeding Suitcase (Flashback)

#162 - The Predator of Predators

#161 - Stories of Survival with Caitlin Van Mol, host of "Lived To Tell"

NMR #64 - Did Daryn Just Ruin John's Life?

#160 - The Mother of Mayhem

Scott Peterson Update (New Evidence and New Trial) (Flashback)

#159 - Who Did This To Billie-Jo?

NMR #63 - Daryn Meets Jodie Foster

#158 - The Appalachian Massacres (Harpe Brothers)

#157 - Who Murdered Marilyn Sheppard?

#156 - Is Scott Peterson Innocent? (with Attorney Sara Azari)

NMR #62 - John's Clone Joins The Show

#155 - Clay Tiffany's Final Days

#154 - Let's Find These Missing People (with Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna)

NMR #61 - Daryn's Gym Nightmares Continue

The Doppelganger Murder (Flashback)

#153 - House of Justice

NMR #60 - Schnooking A Schnookus

#152 - The Cockeyed Cook

#151 - The Killer On Camera

NMR #59 - What's That Thing That Blows Leaves?

#150 - False Teeth, False Justice

#149 - Guilty In The Grave

NMR #58 - Vision PRO-M-G

#148 - Death By Mushrooms

#147 - The District Attorney Is Missing

NMR #57 - The Conclusion of The Grocery Store Mystery

#146 - Natalia Speaks (Reaction)

#145 - Love Has Won: The Cult Of Mother God (Reaction)

NMR #56 - John's Mysterious Grocery Store Boyfriend

#144 - Whose Blood Is In the Van?

Ask Us Anything Q&A (Part 2)

Ask Us Anything Q&A (Part 1)

#143 - The Disappearance of Terrence Woods Jr.

NMR #55 - John's Best Chance With David Archuleta Just Happened!

#142 - The Coast To Coast Killer

#141 - Yosemite National Park Murders

NMR #54 - Floss Then Brush or Brush Then Floss

Market Crash and Murder (Flashback)

#140 - Aileen Wuornos

The Exoneration of Kirstin Lobato (Flashback)

#139 - The TikTok Tragedy

NMR #53 - Stop Changing Baby Diapers on Airplanes

#138 - The Dufflebag of Death

#137 - Screaming For Their Lives

Halloween Spooktacular: Volume 1 - The Runes of Transylvania

#136 - Vampire Mercy Brown

NMR #52 - Should We Go Back to College?

Coming Soon: Halloween Spooktacular (Trailer)

#135 - The Ghost of Dead Woman's Crossing

#134 - The Bean Clan Murders of Scotland

NMR #51 - I'm Your Daddy Now

#133 - Wake Up, It's Time To Die

#132 - The Killer's Notebook

NMR #50 - Live From New York, It's...Us!