All episodes

The Fall River Murders (Flashback)

#131 - Subscription To Death

#130 - The Hidden Gunshot Wound

NMR #49 - Discovering Our Love Languages

#129 - The Bloody Fist Full of Hair

#128 - The Springfield Serial Killer

NMR #48 - Our Uber Ratings

#127 - Left For Dead

#126 - The New York Zodiac Killer

NMR #47 - Daryn Plays Pickleball Now Apparently

#125 - The Curious Case of Natalia Grace (Reaction, Part One)

#124 - Lake Bodom Murders

NMR #46 - Did You Just Say Squirtle?

Ivy League Murder (Flashback)

#123 - The Tragedies of Frank and Viola

#122 - Hollywood Horror In NYC

NMR #45 - Why Is Taylor Swift So Expensive!?

#121 - Desperate In Drag

#120 - Huwe's 30 Years

NMR #44 - Do We Need VR?

#119 - The Bleeding Suitcase

#118 - The Storyville Slayings

NMR #43 - Be Gay, Do Crime

#117 - The Oliver 3, Let's Get Justice

#116 - Killed By A Classmate

NMR #42 - Cat + Patio = Catio

#115 - The Hat Man Murders

#114 - Roadtrip of Death

NMR #41 - Magic's Great Escape

The Haunting of the Island Hotel (Flashback)

#113 - The Murder In Her Head

NMR #40 - No New Potters

#112 - The Deadliest Mistake

#111 - The Doppelganger Murder

NMR #39 - What's Next For Adnan?

#110 - Secrets of The Witch's Castle

#109 - Murdaugh Murders: A Southern Scandal (Reaction)

NMR #38 - Daryn Live At The Oscars

Wrong Wig, Wrong Murder (Flashback)

#108 - Shop Til You Drop Dead

NMR #37 - Check Your Freshies For Real

#107 - Murder and Regret

#106 - The Yellowstone Massacre

NMR #36 - We're Being Abducted By UFOs

#105 - The Potter Family Massacre

#104 - Death on Figueroa Street

NMR #35 - Welcome Home Magic

#103 - Mother Teaches Murder

#102 - Wounded In The Woods

NMR #34 - Daryn's Raccoon Friend

#101 - The Angel of Death

#100 - The Fall River Murders

NMR #33 - None Of You Answered Our Calls

The Coors Brewing Company Murder (Flashback)

Marsha "Pay It No Mind" Johnson (Flashback)

#99 - Casey Anthony: Where The Truth Lies (Reaction)

NMR #32 - MmmBop In The World Cup

#98 - Scott Peterson Update (New Evidence and New Trial)

#97 - The Killer Who Didn't Kill

#96 - Market Crash and Murder

#95 - I Don't Like Mondays (The Brenda Spencer Story)

NMR #31 - John Got Blocked

#94 - The Folsom Wolf In Sheep's Clothing

#93 - The Barron Family Massacre

NMR #30 - Halloween With Jack Daniels

#92 - The Haunting of the Island Hotel

#91 - Vampire Sugar Daddy and The Queen Witch

#90 - The Female Hannibal Lecter

NMR #29 - Dahmer Stays Dah-minating

BONUS: John Reports From Leakin Park and Woodlawn High School

#89 - Jackie The Ripper

NMR #28 - Suffering a Fart Attack

#88 - The Killer's In The Bite

Introducing 'Killer Questions with Daryn Carp' - Who Is Lori Ruff? (with Citizen Detective Kenda Martinez)

#87 - Death In A Bottle

BREAKING: Adnan Syed Released From Prison (Our Reaction and What's Next?)

#86 - Locked And Left For Dead

NMR #27 - John Invades Daryn's Apartment

#85 - I Dreamed of Murder (Flashback)

#84 - Rattlesnake James

#83 - Murdered For Silver (Flashback)

#82 - Haunted To Death

#81 - Her Children Keep Dying

NMR #26 - Daddy Cat, Come On Down!

#80 - The Devil's Pitchfork

#79 - The Coors Brewing Company Murder

NMR #25 - The Cheez-It Saga Continues

#78 - Hypnotized To Hell

#77 - Ivy League Murder

NMR #24 - John's UFO Sightings

#76 - The Murder of Little Boy Blue

#75 - Marsha "Pay It No Mind" Johnson

NMR #23 - Did You Mean To Do That?

#74 - Sous Chef of Death

NMR #22 - In Da Club With A Wig

#73 - Prescription of Death

NMR #21 - RIP John's Fashion Sense

#72 - The Disappearance of Lauren Spierer (Flashback Episode)

#71 - The D.C. Sniper (Flashback Episode)

#70 - To Death or Not To Death