True Crime with Gavin Fish cover art

All Episodes

True Crime with Gavin Fish — 164 episodes

#
Title
1

The Ransom Notes Were Fake? Everything Is Up for Debate. | The Nancy Guthrie Kidnapping

2

These Cases Shouldn't Be Connected, But They Are | Anna Kepner and Lynette Hooker

3

Anonymous Sender Claims Hidden Phone Has Video and Names in Nancy Guthrie Case

4

Have We Been Duped? Experts Say Even 'Authenticated' Nancy Guthrie Ransom Notes Could Be Fake

5

It's Over: Ohio Supreme Court Rejects Mackenzie Shirilla's Final Appeal

6

Closing In on 'Porch Guy.' Did Investigators Miss Their Best Chance? | Nancy Guthrie Update

7

Brian Hooker in the Spotlight: Will Lynette Hooker Get Justice Without Knowing What Really Happened?

8

New Evidence Exposes Brian Hooker's Lies as the US Coast Guard Seizes Dinghy | Lynette Hooker Murder

9

Karen Read Files Explosive Lawsuit Against the Massachusetts State & Canton Police Departments

10

Coast Guard Searches for Lynette Hooker as Murder Case Deepens

11

'Punch in the Gut' — Kouri Richins' Team Wants a New Trial, But They Say They Need More Time.

12

The Timeline Problem—The Defense's SECRET WEAPON—Hidden in Sealed Court Doc | Murder of Anna Kepner

13

Unsealed Doc Reveals Exactly What Prosecutors Say Happened to Anna Kepner on the Carnival Horizon

14

It's More Personal Than Money—Why is this case still unsolved? | What Happened to Nancy Guthrie?

15

Mackenzie Shirilla and the Attention Machine Behind Netflix's 'The Crash'

16

Live True Crime Conversation + Q&A with Special Guest Elizabeth Jones from Hillbilly Crime

17

Judge Tosses All Charges Against Ebony Parker for School Shooting | Shooting of Abigail Zwerner

18

Kouri Richins' Continued Deliberate Jailhouse Smear Campaign

19

A Pregnant Woman Dead, Her Husband Missing, and an International Manhunt | Murder of Christa Gilley

20

'Most Wanted Mom' Fled the Country While Her Son Was Missing | Murder of Noel Rodriguez-Alvarez

21

D4vd's 'Friends' Lived a Fantasy as Celeste Decomposed Nearby | Murder of Celeste Rivas Hernandez

22

Alex Murdaugh's Double Murder Conviction Overturned | SC Supreme Court: “Shocking Jury Interference”

23

D4vd Returns to Court as the Murder Case Moves Closer to Trial | Murder of Celeste Rivas Hernandez

24

The JLR Investigates/Magnolia D.V. Case Looks Way Worse After Seeing the Bodycam Footage

25

D4vd’s Post Murder Interviews Sound Completely Different Now | Murder of Celeste Rivas Hernandez

26

If I Were D4vd’s Lawyer, Here’s the Defense I’d Try | The Death of Celeste Rivas Hernandez

27

FBI Director Takes Aim at Sheriff in Nancy Guthrie Investigation | What Happened to Nancy Guthrie?

28

Celeste’s Death Certificate Was Quietly Changed | Murder of Celeste Rivas Hernandez

29

New D4vd Court Documents Get Even More Disturbing | Murder of Celeste Rivas Hernandez

30

Evidence Dump: How Prosecutors Say D4vd Killed Celeste | Murder of Celeste Rivas Hernandez

31

This is How Nancy Guthrie’s Kidnapper Pulled This Off | What Happened to Nancy Guthrie?

32

What Really Happened Behind the Scenes in the D4vd Case | Murder of Celeste Rivas Hernandez

33

D4vd Might Plead Guilty, That Should Worry You | Murder of Celeste Rivas Hernandez

34

Preliminary Hearing Day for David "D4vd" Anthony Burke | Murder of Celeste Rivas Hernandez

35

Autopsy Report Details Grisly Cause of Death | Murder of Celeste Rivas Hernandez

36

This Case Looks Like a Slam Dunk, But Is it? | D4vd Segregated | Murder of Celeste Rivas Hernandez

37

Live from the Los Angeles Courthouse - Singer D4vd Arraignment | Murder of Celeste Rivas Hernandez

38

D4vd Arrested, But What Took So Long? | Murder of Celeste Rivas Hernandez

39

Are On-Scene YouTubers Hurting the Nancy Guthrie Investigation?

40

Cruise Ship Murder: Anna Kepner’s Last Moments and the Charges Against Her Stepbrother (As an Adult)

41

New Look at the Evidence in the Nancy Guthrie Case | Something’s WAY Off | Where's Nancy?

42

The Truth About How People Disappear (Not What You Think) | Where are Nancy Guthrie & Amy Hillyard?

43

The Sick, Disgusting Plot Against Nancy Guthrie’s Family | This is a Cruel Scam | Where's Nancy?

44

He Confessed to Everything: Rex Heuermann Pleads Guilty in Long Island Serial Killer Case

45

Two Ransom Notes: One Says She’s Alive, the Other Says She’s Dead | Nancy Guthrie Case

46

The 911 Call by Magnolia We Didn't Finish— What Comes Next Is Hard to Hear | JLR Investigates

47

The JLR Investigates Situation is a Train Wreck and I Just Can't Look Away - New Charges, More Audio

48

New Details Reveal What Happened Before Amy Hillyard Disappeared

49

New Details Reveal How Perps Entered Nancy Guthrie’s Home as FBI Data Shows How Rare This Crime Is

50

911 Calls and Dispatch Audio Surface in D.V. Allegation Case Involving JLR Investigates

51

Latest Clues Indicate Nancy Guthrie was Specifically Chosen by Her Kidnappers Because of Savannah

52

Strangulation, Trauma, and Why Victims Stay Silent | The JLR Investigates Allegations

53

Nancy Guthrie: Investigators Keep Changing the Jan. 11 Story

54

JLR Investigates D.V. Allegations: Strangulation Investigator Brian Bennett Weighs In on Report

55

D.V. Allegations Surface in Police Report Involving YouTuber JLR Investigates

56

New Scrutiny on Sheriff’s Decisions as Nancy Guthrie Investigation Drags On

57

New Twist in Ex-NFL Murder Case as ChatGPT Evidence Emerges in Court | Gabriella Carvalho Perpétuo

58

New Break in Nancy Guthrie Case as Genetic Genealogy Expert Says FBI Could Identify Suspect Soon

59

She's a 'Black Widow,' Prosecutor Tells the Jury | Kouri Richins Murder Trial

60

New Twist in the Nancy Guthrie Case as Sheriff Says He Knows the Motive, Others May Be in Danger

61

Cleveland Police Open Suitcases and Make Horrifying Discovery, Mother Arrested | Aliyah Henderson

62

New Polygraph Tests Done in Missing Lilly & Jack Sullivan Case. The Results Raise More Questions.

63

Nancy Guthrie Case: Deputy Criticizes Investigation as Neighbor Reveals More About 'Strange Man'

64

New Twist in Nancy Guthrie Search as Cadaver Dogs Taken Off the Case

65

Could These 3 Weaknesses Create Reasonable Doubt for Kouri Richins? Defense Attorney Weighs In.

66

AMA: Your Questions on the Biggest True Crime Cases | Kouri Richins, Nancy Guthrie and More!

67

Retired FBI Agent Breaks Down the Mind of Nancy Guthrie’s Abductor | Who Kidnapped Nancy?

68

Prosecutors Lay Out Kouri Richins’ Financial Motive | Eric Richins Poisoning Murder Trial, Day 7

69

Searching for Nancy Guthrie: What Law Enforcement Has Tried and Why There’s No Break Yet

70

FBI Desperate to Take Over Case Amid Growing Frustration | What Happened to Nancy Guthrie?

71

New Detail About Suspect’s “Target” Emerges | What Happened to Nancy Guthrie?

72

FBI Visiting Tucson Gun Shops with Images of 40 Persons of Interest in Nancy Guthrie Investigation

73

Nancy Guthrie's Family Cleared, FBI Takes a Forensic Look at the DNA Clues

74

New Info About the Man Tied to Nancy Guthrie’s Kidnapping!

75

Black Glove Found, Detained Man Released, Bitcoin Request Surfaces in Nancy Guthrie Investigation

76

The FBI Has Released Photos and Videos of a Potential Suspect in the Kidnapping of Nancy Guthrie

77

"Hour of Desperation" as Second Ransom Deadline Looms, FBI Still Searching for Body | Nancy Guthrie

78

BREAKING NEWS: FBI Investigating New Letter Sent to Media | What Happened to Nancy Guthrie?

79

Ransom Deadline Passed in Kidnapping of Savannah Guthrie’s Mother | What Happened to Nancy Guthrie?

80

Sheriff & FBI Update on the Kidnapping of Nancy Guthrie as Family Pleads for Her Safe Return

81

Blood on the Ground, Nest Cams Smashed, & Back Door Left Open | What Happened to Nancy Guthrie?

82

Savannah Guthrie's Mom is Missing Out of Arizona. Here's the Latest. | Nancy Guthrie

83

Why Did It Take So Long to Arrest Daniel Martell? What Else Is He Hiding? | Lilly & Jack Sullivan

84

Expert: Strangulation Is the Most Dangerous Warning Sign | Spencer & Monique Tepe Murders

85

Affidavit Says Michael McKee Stalked the Tepe's Home Weeks Before the Spencer & Monique Tepe Murders

86

Privilege May Have Led to Alleged Double Murder | The Rob Reiner and Michele Singer Murders

87

Grand Jury Witness Arrested | Will D4vd Face the Music Soon? | Murder of Celeste Rivas Hernandez

88

Michael McKee In an Ohio Court Today in Ex-Wife & Husband's Murder | Spencer & Monique Tepe Murders

89

Feds Are Looking Into Corruption & Nobody Says What It Means... Except Me | Ellen Greenberg Murder

90

Nick Reiner Reportedly 'Childlike' & 'Delirious' in Jail | The Rob Reiner and Michele Singer Murders

91

The Philly GRAVE ROBBER Case — The Details Are Unthinkable! | Jonathan Gerlach

92

Chilling New Details Emerge In Ohio Dentist & Wife Murders | Spencer & Monique Tepe Murders

93

A Deadly Mix? Meth and Medication in the Reiner Case | The Rob Reiner and Michele Singer Murders

94

She Was in Constant Fear of Him + Police Say They Found the Weapon | Spencer & Monique Tepe Murders

95

HUGE News in the Ellen Greenberg Investigation - The Feds Are Investigating & Have Issued Subpoenas

96

Brendan Banfield Murder Trial — Au Pair Testifies | The Murder of Christine Banfield and Joseph Ryan

97

Details Are In About Michael McKee | Why'd He (Allegedly) Do It? | Spencer & Monique Tepe Murders

98

Arrest Made in Double Murder of Columbus Ohio Dentist and Wife | Spencer & Monique Tepe Murders

99

What We Know About Spencer & Monique Tepe | What Was the Motive? | Spencer & Monique Tepe Murders

100

More 9-1-1 Audio Released in Ohio Double Murder Case | Spencer & Monique Tepe Murders

101

Nick Reiner Loses His High Profile Celebrity Lawyer | The Rob Reiner and Michele Singer Murders

102

Two Bodies Found in Ohio Home, Police Seek Person of Interest | Spencer & Monique Tepe Murders

103

Inside Nick Reiner’s Defense and the Warnings Police Had | The Rob Reiner and Michele Singer Murders

104

Should the Judge Recuse Himself in Mickey Stines' Case? | The Murder of Kentucky Judge Kevin Mullins

105

The Question Police Still Haven’t Answered | The Hollywood Homicide of Rob Reiner and Michele Singer

106

Defense’s Version of Events Raises Serious Questions | The Murder of Kentucky Judge Kevin Mullins

107

What Makes Someone Kill Their Own Parents? | The Hollywood Homicide of Rob Reiner and Michele Singer

108

Ashlee Buzzard is Under Arrest in the Death of MELODEE BUZZARD!

109

The Night Before the Reiner Murders | The Hollywood Homicide of Rob Reiner and Michele Singer

110

Nick Reiner’s Mental Decline | The Hollywood Homicide of Rob Reiner and Michele Singer

111

Timeline of Nick Reiner's Alleged Crime | The Hollywood Homicide of Rob Reiner and Michele Singer

112

Inside the Mind of Nick Reiner | The Hollywood Homicide of Rob Reiner and Michele Singer

113

Hollywood Homicide: Son Charged in Rob and Michele Reiner Murders

114

Brian Walshe Found Guilty of First Degree Murder | Is This Justice for Ana Walshe?

115

Ah, the 'He Loved Her So He Did the Hacky-Hacky' Defense | Brian Walshe Murder Trial, Day 10 Recap

116

The Defense Rests??? | Brian Walshe Murder Trial, Day 9 Recap | The Murder of Ana Walshe

117

The State Rests | Brian Walshe Murder Trial, Day 8 Recap | The Murder of Ana Walshe

118

She Thought He Liked Her. What Happened Next Is Unthinkable. | The Murder of Danika Troy

119

M.E. Testifies! | Brian Walshe Murder Trial, Day 6 Recap & Discussion | Murder of Ana Walshe

120

Court: We Won't Be Releasing That Information Publicly | The Murder of Kentucky Judge Kevin Mullins

121

Ana's Lover Testifies | Brian Walshe Murder Trial, Day 4 Recap & Discussion | Murder of Ana Walshe

122

Brian Walshe Murder Trial, Day 3 Recap & Discussion | More Forensic Evidence | Murder of Ana Walshe

123

Brian Walshe Murder Trial, Day 2 Recap & Discussion | Murder of Ana Walshe

124

Brian Walshe Murder Trial, Day 1 Recap & Discussion | Murder of Ana Walshe

125

This Week’s Recap: Celeste Rivas Hernandez, Anna Kepner, Ana Walshe, Caitlin Tracey & More

126

The Case Against Barry Morphew is Strong | Suzanne Morphew Murder

127

Morgan Geyser Captured, Bodycam Shows Arrest as Slender Man Case Returns to Court

128

LAPD Source Reportedly Says D4vd Did Not Act Alone | Murder of Celeste Rivas Hernandez

129

This Week’s Recap: Celeste Rivas Hernandez, Anna Kepner, Kada Scott, Ana Walshe, & More

130

Court Docs Signal Charges for Anna Kepner's 16-Year-Old Stepbrother May Be Coming Soon

131

A Guilty Plea Nobody Saw Coming: Analyzing Brian Walshe's Latest Move with Joshua Ritter from Courtroom Confidential

132

The Last Stop Before Trial in the Grisly Murder of Massachusetts Mom Ana Walshe

133

This Week’s Recap: Mullins/Stines, Caitlin Tracey, Melodee Buzzard, Celeste Rivas Hernandez, & More

134

The Evidence That Changed Everything in the Caitlin Tracey Case

135

Melodee Buzzard May Be Alive in Utah | Ashlee Buzzard Released

136

How Is This Not a Crime? LAPD Issues Telling Update | Death of Celeste Rivas Hernandez

137

Where There's One, There's 300 | Another Woman Comes Forward About Kentucky Judge Kevin Mullins

138

Melodee Buzzard's Mom Arrested, +This Week’s Recap: Mullins/Stines, Jake Haro, & More

139

New Leaks, Old Lies: The Latest Twists in the Judge Mullins Murder

140

He Finally Faced Justice After Killing His 7-Month-Old Son | The Emmanuel Haro Murder

141

JLR’s Disaster Move and the Morphew Family’s Strange Unity | Suzanne Morphew Murder

142

What Really Happened to Kada Scott with Forensic Expert Joseph Scott Morgan

143

What It Takes to Tell the Hard Stories with My True Crime Bestie, Sherrilyn Dale

144

Investigation Uncovers Disturbing Items at D4vd’s Home | Death of Celeste Rivas Hernandez

145

Why the FBI Just Stepped In: Melodee Buzzard’s Disappearance Gets Chilling Update

146

This Week’s Recap: Judge Kevin Mullins, Mickey Stines, Lilly & Jack Sullivan, Kada Scott, and More

147

Even More Answers Coming Out of Letcher County! | Judge Kevin Mullins Murder

148

Every Chilling Detail in the Keon King Murder Affidavit | Hint: He Had Help | Kada Scott Murder

149

We’re Starting to See the Truth About What Happened to Kada Scott

150

Unimaginable Cruelty: 4-Year-Old Found Weighing Only 21 Pounds | Murder of Isaiah Dionne

151

This Week’s Update: Ellen Greenberg, Donna Adelson, Jake Haro, Celeste Rivas Hernandez, and More

152

Ellen Greenberg's Parents Join Me to Discuss Their Fight for Justice and What Comes Next

153

Breaking Down the Latest in the D4vd Investigation and the Death of Celeste Rivas Hernandez

154

Can the Judge Do Anything About The Medical Examiner's 'Independent' Report About Ellen Greenberg?

155

I Can't Believe What the New Medical Examiner Just Said About Ellen Greenberg's Murder

156

Friday Free-For-All: Let’s Hang Out and Talk About Whatever

157

The Questions No One Can Seem to Answer in the Laken Snelling Case

158

Legal Analysis of the Ellen Greenberg Murder with Joshua Ritter from Courtroom Confidential

159

A Suspected Serial Killer Has Been Arrested for Three 1977 SoCal Slayings | Warren Luther Alexander

160

Disturbed: A Gruesome Murder in 'Safest City in America' | Shocking Details Released

161

Stephan Sterns' Twisted Mind and the Doll Torso

162

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court Will Hear Appeal on Ellen Greenberg Case

163

Do Stephan Sterns' Parents Know All About His Private Escapades?

164

In First Interview, 'Pastor' JP Miller Says Mica Francis Miller's Death is Not His Fault