Left Out in the Cold: The Real Consequences for Good Behavior in Schools

Although no one is reporting on it, schools continue to treat students worse than they did in the before times. People complain that there are no consequences for bad behavior, as if this explains the ongoing quagmire, but the bigger issue is that there are no longer consequences for GOOD behavior. Virtual school showed schools what they can get away with in their treatment of kids, and that is how many continue to treat them. Full stop.These kids are achievers. Many get to school early, really early. Baltimore City Public Schools do not use classic school buses; students ride public transportation. Baltimore City College students come from the top 20% of Baltimore City Schools middle schools, and many take two or three buses and have a walk to get to school. Some parents even drive their kids across town before work for the opportunity to attend City. Before Covid, shortly after we opened the doors at 6:30 am, students would enter through the loading dock doors and sit in the cafeteria, where they could eat the free breakfast provided by Baltimore City Schools for all students.During 2022-2023, about 35 students were shot on or around their high school campus; 6 died. And City is not immune to crime. We’ve had volunteers walk our students from bus stops to keep them safe; at least one student was carjacked in the student lot, a teacher was mugged in the teacher lot, and multiple students have been stabbed and shot at the bus stop.Amari’s testimony isn’t just about being cold; it's about a systemic failure that affects many students like him. He represents those who do everything right—waking up early, commuting long distances, and showing up eager to learn. Yet, instead of being welcomed, they’re left outside in the cold, both literally and figuratively.When Amari says, "Every time I'm here, there's always a bunch of kids out here standing in the cold," it's not just about discomfort—it's neglect. Amari’s experience reflects the reality for many students (and their families) who are dedicated and committed but overlooked. The message is clear: good behavior and effort no longer matter. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit jennibgaither.substack.com