Skip to content
Monitoring Progress towards SDGs through Public Spending episode artwork

Jul 27, 2020 16 min

Monitoring Progress towards SDGs through Public Spending

from ParlAmericas Podcast Hosted by ParlAmericas

This episode examines the opportunity to use money as a lens to evaluate the government’s policy priorities and results, and to strengthen fiscal scrutiny practices to better oversee progress on the implementation of the 2030 Agenda. Dr. Helaina Gaspard, Director of Governance and Institutions at the Institute for Fiscal Studies and Democracy (IFSD) at the University of Ottawa provides an overview of how the national budget process is an important avenue through which parliaments can monitor and evaluate progress towards the SDGs, since it is the main policy instrument that identifies annual revenue expectations and spending priorities. This presentation was recorded at the 16th ParlAmericas Plenary Assembly, Accelerating Progress on Agenda 2030: Good Practices for Parliamentary Action, taking place in Asuncion, Paraguay from October 30th to November 1st, 2019.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

In this episode, recorded during the 16th ParlAmericas Plenary Assembly in the training session on “Monitoring Progress towards SDGs through Public Spending”, Dr. Helaina Gaspard, Director of Governance and Institutions at the Institute for Fiscal Studies and Democracy (IFSD) at the University of Ottawa examines the opportunity to use money as a lens to evaluate the government’s policy priorities and results and to strengthen fiscal scrutiny practices to better oversee progress on the implementation of the 2030 Agenda.

Ready to play

Monitoring Progress towards SDGs through Public Spending

0:00 16:50
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

In this episode, recorded during the 16th Parlamerica's Plenary Assembly in the training session on monitoring progress towards SDGs through public spending, Dr. Elena Gaspard, Director of Governance and Institutions at the Institute for Fiscal Studies and Democracy at the University of Ottawa, examines the opportunity to use money as a lens to evaluate the government's policy priorities and results and to strengthen fiscal scrutiny practices to better oversee progress on the implementation of the 2030 Agenda. Good afternoon, everyone. It's a pleasure to be with you here today. To all of my Spanish-speaking colleagues, my sincere apologies that I am not more proficient and that I don't speak Spanish. And we thank our colleagues from Paraguay for their wonderful welcome. I'm here today to talk a bit about the Sustainable Development Goals and how we can use money as a lens to think about progress and to track progress on these really important goals. And we know that the SDGs, pardon me as I catch up here, are certainly ambitious goals.

There are 17 ambitious goals. There are integrated goals. And these are goals that are going to cross governments, that are going to cross mandates, and that will not be accomplished in any short period of time. I think we're very fortunate here today to have so many countries represented and so many experiences represented as well. And I do hope that you'll draw on those experiences during the workshop and share them with your colleagues because there is so much to learn.

Since these are no easy feat, there's a great deal of information that you need and sometimes also that's missing when it comes to thinking about and evaluating and tracking the progress of the SDGs. But despite these challenges, parliamentarians have a very, very important role to play in monitoring and scrutinizing government action or inaction among the SDGs. What I'd like to have us spend some time doing today is talk about how we can use money, talk about how we can use the financial cycle to better understand what's happening or what's not happening in our individual country context relative to the SDGs. And so Parliament, Congress, to us is so important because you control the purse strings, right? This foundational, this core element of democracy really resides with you. The buck stops with you, so to speak, because you can either approve spending, reject spending, and in some situations amend proposals or even make your own proposals.

And so your role becomes quite interesting and quite important because you have different moments throughout the financial cycle to be able to leverage these different tools and to be able to act on them. And so as we zero in on fiscal scrutiny, I want to emphasize that this is not only about adding and subtracting. Fiscal scrutiny, understanding performance, understanding outcomes, is about much more than dollars and cents. It's actually what's being done with the money. How are we using money to understand a problem? How are we using money to solve a problem? How are we using money to incentivize a different outcome? That's what fiscal scrutiny is all about. And that's why your roles throughout the financial cycle become important tools.

So just to give you an example, rather an anecdote from Canada as to why money becomes interesting, we were asked the question, who is the most warmongering prime minister? Who spent the most on defense? And at the time, we had a prime minister who was very openly in favor of the armed forces and made a number of pronouncements of support. When we looked at the money, however, it was actually a prime minister that was perceived to be quite pacifist, that was actually the single largest spender in defense in Canada. And so that's why we like money. Money sometimes doesn't lie.

So we'll start our chat today, and I do hope that we'll turn this into a bit of a dialogue. I'm sure you don't want to listen to me for the next 30 minutes. So please intervene, and I would love to hear what's happening in your own countries, and I'll be sure to raise a few of the examples in the hopes that you'll share. So just to start off fairly broad, I want to talk about why we care about money. And when we think about money from a public perspective, and we think about money as a lens for analysis, we have a fellow, Alan Schick, who is a fellow at the Brookings Institute and who's also a former professor from the University of Maryland. And this godfather of budgeting says when we think about public spending, we think about it in three ways.

The first is aggregate fiscal discipline. Can we balance the books over time? So are you making prudent, reasonable, sensible decisions within your economic and fiscal constraints? So if you're running major deficits, are you spending more? If your country is severely indebted, are you spending more or are you finding ways to manage that, to bring that in? So that's the big picture. That's aggregate fiscal discipline.

The second for us is allocative efficiency. I love allocative efficiency because this is the best way to test political commitment. When we're thinking about allocative efficiency, it's whether or not you're aligning your spending to your priorities. So if you're a government of the day, are you spending where you're claiming to want to have the most impact? Are you spending in a way that's commensurate to your goals?

And then finally, there's the question of operational efficiency. Operational efficiency is likely the most difficult of all of these three categories because it's all about performance. What results are we getting for spending? What results is spending generating on the ground? And certainly, what do citizens perceive? We ran analysis like this actually in Canada and looked back many, many years. And what we found was that governments in an election year, whether they run a budgetary surplus or whether they run a deficit, are just as likely to be re-elected. Where incumbent governments actually fell was on the operational issue.

Their perceived performance, the perceived lack of results or failure to achieve results or failure in management ended up being far more powerful relative to the citizenry than a straight deficit or budgetary balance. So do keep that in mind. We'll drill down now a little bit further. specifically on the issue or on the question of SDGs. And so when we're thinking about putting this question, this issue of fiscal scrutiny into practice, I want to talk about it at three different levels. So the first, and we're going to connect this to the frame, to Schick's frame that we just discussed. So the first is the issue of contextual analysis. And this, again, is the broad economic goal, the broad economic context in which your government, in which you as parliamentarians are operating.

So we want to know, can the government actually act? Can they afford to act on SDGs? And this is certainly a question that you as parliamentarians are likely asking yourselves. And so you're thinking, is the economy healthy? Is the economy sustainable? Are we going to be borrowing money to do this? Or are these challenges or these programs that we are going to invest from existing pots of money, so to speak? The second is the issue of planning.

And I want you to think about planning throughout the financial cycle, because it's what the executive is doing, how the executive is planning on undertaking its different goals. So has the government even made commitments relative to the SDGs? And when they've, or if they've made commitments, are they talking about program commitments? Are they talking about, you know, legislative change? What are they doing to demonstrate that they're actually going to act in this area? And then the last is the question of performance evaluation. And this again becomes tricky, because it's that operational efficiency question that comes into play. And the reason it's challenging is because it's about the monitoring of the SDGs.

And monitoring anything, let alone broad, integrated, sustainable development goals, isn't always easy, right? We know that some governments, like Mexico, if I'm not mistaken, actually has an online portal, and that's dedicated to the tracking of the SDGs. Do I have that right? And you can actually access, I'm seeing some of the senators nodding, that you can actually access this information. And so you can see how the government is faring, whether or not these goals are actually being achieved. And so those are actually quite important considerations to keep in mind. And also, no one needs to say to you as parliamentarians that there is sometimes a mismatch in information. I know certainly those that come from parliamentary systems, say, for instance, a Westminster system like that that we have in Canada, it's definitely a challenge, because as a parliamentarian, I see some people smiling, you are out-resourced and you are out-gunned relative to the executive branch, right?

So those are contextual considerations that you also might want to account for as you're thinking about the question of SDGs. When we think about tracking SDGs specifically, there are a few things that we think might be helpful to keep in mind and three levels really at which, as parliamentarians, you may wish to act on. So the first is, you know, the proposals for action. What's being done? The second is the allocation of resources, right? Using money as your lens. Is money being allocated to a goal? Is money being allocated to these activities? And then lastly, the question of performance assessment. Do you have the information that you need to do your job and to track over time?

We want to draw your attention now to some of the different resources or some of the different opportunities you may have as a parliamentarian to find support, to find data from the outside. When we're looking again at those three levels of analysis, the proposals for consideration. So if you want to act on an SDG, if, say, you're a member of a committee and you're tasked, say, with gender-based violence, of helping to alleviate gender-based violence in your country, and you're looking for proposals, you're looking for things to put forward, where do you go as a parliamentarian? You go to your budget office. So your budget office offers you proposals, okay?

Where else might you go from your own experiences to find ideas, to find proposals for activity? Oh, statistics, right, absolutely. So you're trying to actually contextually understand what's happening. Absolutely. So you may look inside of government. There may be times that you look outside as well. You may look, say, for instance, to civil society organizations. You may call up a think tank like ours. You may go to a university professor who's an expert in the area. But the idea is that when you're thinking about proposals for action and you are thinking about acting on any of the SDGs, part of the collection of these proposals, part of this understanding of your context, whether through budgetary or statistical lenses, becomes this accumulation of ideas, right? Directionally, empirically, what makes sense? What are the most effective ways that you can act on the SDGs?

Then there's the question of the allocation of resources, right? What would be a sensible amount of money? What amount of money is needed to actually be able to act in these areas? And so some of you may go to your budget offices. Some of you may go to your ministries of finance. Others, again, might consult on the outside. But the idea is not to forget that you're part of a complete system. You have your parliamentary committees. You may even have your own party apparatuses that might help to act in this area. And then finally, to figure out whether or not the activities worked, you have all kinds of performance assessments.

Your supreme audit institutions, whether you have an auditor general or the like, they would be wonderful resources at the end of the financial cycle to see what happened with the program, to see what was actually spent and what was actually delivered. You might have a parliamentary committee that's doing work on an interim basis, tracking that program activity, tracking those outcomes. You may again have civil society intervening. So there are a host of actors and a host of resources that you have. And I do believe you have a draft copy.

of the Fiscal Accountability Handbook. And I do hope that we'll receive your feedback and that Parliament Americans will receive your feedback on this particular tool because the tool is designed with you in mind, right? The tool is designed to pick apart the financial cycle and really to think methodically throughout it that as a parliamentarian, as a very busy parliamentarian, where can you best leverage, how can you best leverage the resources at your disposal to do your job as effectively as possible? So oftentimes, from my experience certainly watching what a number of you folks do in parliaments, We sometimes have to support the piecing together of resources. We often at our think tank get calls from the different political parties in Canada saying, you know, we're looking at this issue, can you help me with this? Or we're trying to better understand First Nations child welfare. Can you cost what an intervention might look like? So these are questions that were asked, and I expect if our parliamentarians are asking, you must be asking the same questions.

And so when it comes to the SDGs, starting to put together that network of people, putting together those resources becomes so, so important for you. Because these are big questions, right? No single government is going to solve an SDG overnight. SDGs are going to be incremental progress, likely over years. And so the more actors, the more elements of your fiscal ecosystem, you know, of your own political ecosystems that can be involved and that can play a part, the better the opportunities are for sustainable change and certainly for sustainable development as well. So whether you're looking to NGOs, whether you're looking to your own parliamentary committees, I mean, sometimes...

Looking to other countries as well can also be helpful. We know, for instance, that Jamaica has connected in with other colleagues in the Caribbean and that their own statistical agency is now monitoring progress. I think it's SDG 6 on water and the usability and potability of water. And so there are a number of different ways that parliamentarians and that countries can certainly act. And having parliamentarians there to help push them along can be quite important and, frankly, necessary. And so when we think about your role as a parliamentarian and the way that it extends, you extend really throughout the entire financial cycle.

So it's not just about is the money in appropriations going out the door enough to be able to solve a problem, enough to achieve a particular program goal. But your role extends all the way through, right, through to the public accounts. Did the money actually do what it was expected to do? Are you actually generating results for what you were expected to do or what you expected the government to do? That's why your role is so important here, because it's not a single intervention, it's not a single action, and that's going to make these sustainable changes.

So there is a great deal of variance as well among countries and among activities. I mentioned a few, but I expect that or suspect that there must be so much more activity happening at your individual country levels. And we do hope that in the balance of the discussion today, and certainly when we take up the case study, that we'll have an opportunity to hear from more of you in terms of what you're doing and how you're working to achieve progress on some of these SDGs. Absolutely, you do have a solid point of departure, however. There's global consensus on SDGs, and typically when a government is choosing to act on SDGs, they definitely need the support of Parliament to be able to do so, because without Parliament you can't unlock any money, you can't unlock any of those resources. And so if public service generally is about making sure the lives of your citizens are improved, the SDGs are certainly an excellent starting point.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of ParlAmericas Podcast?

This episode is 16 minutes long.

When was this ParlAmericas Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on July 27, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this ParlAmericas Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.