All episodes
Somerton Man
MAILBAG: Tinker Bell is a Needy B*tch
White House & DC Ghosts
Bohemian Grove
Mini Crawlers: Another Craig Coincidence
MAILBAG: Mysterious Packages
Nellie Bly: Investigative Journalist
LIVE Call-In Show: November 6th
Mini Crawlers: Craig's Synchronicity
Circleville Letters
MAILBAG: Cursed Vacations & Tori Amos
Seance with John E.L. Tenney
Mini Crawlers: The Bell Witch
MAILBAG: Haunted Buick & Baby Hats
Cannibals: Issei Sagawa & Gilberto Valle aka Cannibal Cop
The Hat Man: Sleep Paralysis Demon
MAILBAG: Cannibal Puppeteer
Smurl Family Haunting
Hammersmith Ghost & Walpurga Hausmännin
MAILBAG: Creepy Crawlers
Oakland County Child Murders & North Fox Island
LIVE Call-In Show: October 2nd
MAILBAG: Casa by the Sea & Guacamole
NXIVM & DOS
Mini Crawlers: Provo Canyon School & The "Troubled Teen" Industry
MAILBAG: County Coroner Cottage Core
The Eerie History Of Bellingham, Washington
Mini Crawlers: Human RFID Chip Implants
MAILBAG: Always Darkest Before The Dawn
Savopoulos DC Mansion Murders
Mini Crawlers: Love Has Won Cult
MAILBAG: Burying a Human Skull & Attempted Cult Kidnapping
Riven Rock: The McCormick's Sex Mansion
LIVE Call-In Show: September 4th
MAILBAG: The Goatman
Hwaseong Strangler: The Zodiac of South Korea
LIVE Call-In Show: August 28th
MAILBAG: White Oleander
Bethel Church: Cult?
LIVE Call-In Show: August 21st
MAILBAG: Melon Heads & Guardian Angels
Flat Earthers Part 2: Interview with Mark Sargent
Flat Earthers Part 1
LIVE Call-In Show: August 14th
MAILBAG: Death Row Inmate Calls A Listener
Louise Huebner: Official Witch of Los Angeles
LIVE Call-In Show: August 7th
MAILBAG: Trader Joe's Snacks & Deadly Potatoes
Radium Girls
LIVE Call-In Show: July 31st
MAILBAG: Elephant Graveyard
Samaritan Foundation Cult & Missing Allen Ross
MAILBAG: Serial Killer Themed Hotel & Jeb's Nemesis
MAILBAG: Pyramid Scheme Victim & Found Ghost Story
The Lost Colony of Roanoke
Mini Crawlers: Kalamazoo Witchcraft Murder & Pervert Park
MAILBAG: Dank Memes & Dirty Diana
Women-Led Cult: Blackburn
Mini Crawlers: Museum of Ice Cream Torture Chambers
MAILBAG & Jeb's Voicemails
Pont-Saint-Esprit Poisoning
Mini Crawlers: Ghislaine Maxwell is Arrested
MAILBAG! Lunch with John Wayne Gacy
Murder of Richard Oland
MAILBAG: Maria Meets Shia Labeouf
Psychic Jessica Lanyadoo Talks To Our Pets
H.H. Holmes and the Murder Hotel
Mini Crawlers: Nicolas Cage
MAILBAG & Lori Vallow's Missing Children Update
The Source Family
Mini Crawlers: Louise Peete
Mini Crawlers: Australian Tinder Killer
Missing: Johnny Gosch
The Alarmist Amelia Earhart Bonus!
MAILBAG & Papa Roach
Chicago Ghosts with Dale Kaczmarek
Amelia Earhart with The Alarmist's Rebecca Delgado Smith
Glitches & Simulations with John E.L. Tenney
Urban Legends with Paul F. Tompkins
Mini Crawlers: Creepy TikToks & Listener Mail
Waco Siege
Mini Crawlers: Purple People Cult & One Taste
Mini Crawlers: Jersey Devil & Simulations
Mini Crawlers: Bigfoot
Mini Crawlers: Loch Ness Monster
Natalia Grace: Abandoned Orphan or Adult?
Mini Crawlers: Chupacabra & Mailbag
Mini Crawlers: Lottery Curses
Mini Crawlers: Mailbag & Annabelle Doll
Mini Crawlers: Jejune Institute
Rasputin
Fast Food Rumors & Food Scientist Interview
Mini Crawlers: Lydia Greengrass-DeAlvaladejo
Mini Crawlers: Dating Game Killer
Mini Crawlers: Waverly Hills Sanatorium
Sarah Lawrence Cult
MAILBAG & True Crime Documentaries
Mini Crawlers: Gardner Museum Art Heist
Mini Crawlers: Spontaneous Combustion of Mary Reeser
Mini Crawlers: Ali's Soulmate & Pentagon Confirms UFOs