Holy Banter: St. Alphonsus Liguori Catholic Church Podcast

In this episode of Holy Banter, Christina and Andrea sit down with seminarian Josiah Lewis to hear the story of his journey toward the priesthood—and what God has taught him along the way. Josiah shares how his vocation hasn’t been one dramatic “yes,” but rather a series of small yeses, each requiring him to surrender his desire for control and trust God with the next step.Together, they talk about discernment, surrender, the desire to know what comes next, and learning to trust that we don't have to see the whole path—we just have to take the next step God puts in front of us.Whether you're discerning a vocation, making a big decision, or simply trying to follow God more faithfully, Josiah's story is a beautiful reminder that God often leads us one yes at a time.

What happens when you've spent a lifetime searching for success, reinventing yourself, and chasing the next thing—only to discover that what you're really looking for can't be found in a career, a city, or a paycheck?  In this episode of Holy Banter, Lisa Wykoff shares her remarkable journey from what she calls "bubblegum Christianity" to becoming Catholic at this year's Easter Vigil. Along the way, she reflects on life in Chicago, Atlanta, and Hilton Head, a stint in stand-up comedy, the heartbreak of starting over, a powerful spiritual awakening during COVID, and the unexpected path that led her to the Catholic Church.  With honesty, humor, and plenty of laughs, Lisa opens up about faith, identity, spiritual warfare, and the moment she realized that true success isn't found in what you achieve—it's found in who you are as a child of God.

Join us for a conversation with Mat Lageman—a former Hollywood actor, voice performer, comedian, recovering alcoholic, devoted father, and the man behind one of the most memorable photos in our parish directory. From performing with Second City and working in Los Angeles to voicing a villainous tumor in a horror movie, Mat's life has been full of unexpected twists. But when God called him away from the spotlight and into a completely different role, Mat discovered a deeper purpose than he ever imagined. Filled with hilarious stories, hard-earned wisdom, and moving reflections on sobriety, fatherhood, faith, and surrender, this episode is a powerful reminder that God's plans are often far better—and far stranger—than our own.

In this episode of Holy Banter, Christina and Andrea sit down with newlyweds Nick and Lexi Krier to explore their remarkable faith journeys and what led them to become passionate volunteers in St. Alphonsus Liguori's middle school ministry. Lexi shares her path from a non-denominational Christian upbringing to entering the Catholic Church through OCIA, describing the mentors, friendships, and experiences that helped her discover the beauty of Catholicism and the Eucharist. Nick reflects on growing up Catholic, rediscovering his faith in college through the St. Thomas Aquinas Catholic Center at Purdue, and how community and retreats transformed his relationship with Christ. Together, they discuss dating across denominations, preparing for marriage, the importance of prayer and accountability, and the role of authentic Christian friendships in shaping a life of faith.

Christina Steele and Andrea Simpson sit down with Father Jacob Miller just days before his ordination to the priesthood. Father Jacob shares his inspiring journey from a small rural town in eastern Indiana to answering God's call to become a priest. He reflects on a powerful encounter with God's voice during his Confirmation, the years he spent discerning between marriage and priesthood, and the mentors who helped guide him along the way. Filled with humor, heartfelt stories, and profound insights on prayer, vocation, and the love of the Sacred Heart of Jesus, this conversation offers a moving look at how God patiently leads us to discover His plan for our lives. Whether you're discerning a vocation, seeking to deepen your faith, or simply love hearing powerful stories of God's work in ordinary lives, this is an episode you won't want to miss.

Join us as Jenny Bryans shares her inspiring journey of faith, resilience, and community. Discover how moving across countries, caring for a sibling with disabilities, and a transformative Marian encounter deepened her spirituality. Jenny reveals the power of the rosary and adoration in overcoming life's challenges. Whether you're seeking inspiration or practical faith insights, this episode offers heartfelt stories and valuable lessons on trust, devotion, and the strength found in community.

Join Christina Steele and Andrea Simpson as they chat with Kristi Powers, director of youth ministry at St. Alphonsus, about her faith journey, ministry, and balancing family life. Hear how growing up in Oklahoma's mission territory and experiences with youth ministry at a tiny parish shaped her passion for the catholic faith.  She shares unique stories about her Deacon Dad's assignment authenticating relics and participating in exorcisms and going into labor at NCYC!  This episode contains spiritual wisdom and beautiful stores of how God works in our lives.

This podcast explores the profound impact of COVID-19 on Clinton Bohm's faith journey, revealing the deep significance of the Eucharist and strengthening family bonds. Discover how a simple King's Hawaiian roll became a surprising opening to faith and transformation, illustrating how unexpected moments can reveal profound insights.

Most of us underestimate the transformative power of community in deepening faith. Daryl and Brenda's story reveals how authentic relationships—built on faith, vulnerability, and service—can anchor us through life's toughest storms and lead us to genuine spiritual renewal.  They explore how shared faith and small acts of kindness create a ripple effect that transforms individual lives and entire parishes.  Their story is a reminder that faith is not only personal but communal—an ongoing journey that finds its strength in authentic relationships and persistent prayer.  Perfect for anyone seeking to rekindle their faith, build stronger community bonds, or find inspiration in life's hardships, this episode proves that, through connection and faith-centered service, we can turn ordinary moments into extraordinary grace. 

Logan and Lauren Gauker’s story of discovering their vocations, faith and each other is a journey of purpose, prayer and perseverance that will inspire anyone wrestling with life’s big questions.

In this deeply moving episode, Anne Jones shares her powerful journey through unimaginable loss—including the deaths of her sister, mother, husband, and daughter—and how her faith carried her through it all. With honesty, wisdom, and even moments of humor, Anne reflects on the reality of grief, the importance of community, and the choice to run toward God instead of away from Him.

Jeff Franciskovich’s journey from heartbreak to hope is a powerful testament to resilience and divine mercy. After enduring a devastating divorce, Jeff found himself in his darkest moments, feeling alone and overwhelmed. However, a profound encounter with Christ during a retreat transformed his despair into unshakable faith, demonstrating that even in life's trials, God's presence offers peace and healing. This episode delves into the significance of surrendering to God's plan and moving forward with resolve despite setbacks. Jeff’s reflections on forgiveness and divine encounters inspire listeners to embrace trials as opportunities for growth. His journey offers encouragement that through God’s grace, healing and new beginnings are possible. Perfect for anyone seeking peace amid suffering or looking to deepen their relationship with Christ, Jeff’s story serves as a reminder that we are never alone in our struggles.

Andrea and Christina have a conversation with Marcellino D'Ambrosio, also known as Dr. Italy, about his journey from secular musician to passionate evangelist. He reveals how faith should be an adventure filled with joy and humor. Discover how a life-changing encounter with Jesus transformed his world, leading him from the club scene to the depths of faith. This episode is a call to live fully alive in Christ, perfect for anyone seeking inspiration and a life filled with authentic joy.

Husband and father Dan Nield shares how he discovered his calling to help others reach heaven through the unique gifts God gave him. He opens up about the transformative role community has played in his faith journey, why tithing has become central to his family's life and the surprisingly powerful impact of sharing faith in small, everyday moments.

St. Alphonsus parishioner Mary Stall, part of the first class of women admitted to the University of Notre Dame, shares the story of her return to the Catholic Church as an adult. Hear Mary's story of faith, the silent retreat that inspired her return and how she continues to grow in holiness today.

In a world filled with distractions and uncertainties, the journey of faith can often be complex and deeply personal. In this episode of Holy Banter, Father Tyler Kreipke shares how a Zionsville Methodist kid became a Catholic priest in the Congregation of Holy Cross—through invitation, prayer, and the slow draw of grace. From engineering and Notre Dame to seminary and ministry in Portland, Oregon, he reflects on listening for God’s call, the power of community, and the hope of Romans 8.

Kim Marks shares her deeply personal journey of faith—from growing up Catholic to encountering God in a more intimate, life-changing way through daily Mass, Scripture, the Eucharist, and surrender. Kim reflects on motherhood, suffering, trust, and courage, including walking with her daughter through anorexia, and how God continues to meet her in both the ordinary and the profound. A beautiful conversation about docility, hope, and letting God lead.

In this special episode of Holy Banter, we reflect with gratitude on our journey, with co-host Annie Sweeney sharing her final moments on the podcast. The conversation reflects on the friendships and God moments that have shaped Holy Banter. As we head into the new year, Christina joyfully sHoly Banter will return with a new episode on January 1, 2026.

Matt and Colleen Deryckere share the heartbreaking story of their firstborn son Ryan, whose short life changed everything. From an emergency delivery and time in the NICU at Riley, to planning a funeral no parent imagines, they talk honestly about anger, sorrow, and the slow work of healing. Along the way, they share how Ryan’s baptism, a late–night visit from a priest, and the love of their community opened the door to Colleen’s conversion, renewed faith, and a family mission of remembrance and hope.

Fresh from hours of silence, Annie and Christina talk with Fr. Huemmer about discerning God’s voice, the beauty of Ignatian spirituality, and how retreats shape a deeper life of prayer. He reflects on his vocation story, the movements of the heart, and why moments of stillness can lead us closer to Christ.

Three longtime friends from St. Alphonsus—Penny Edmondson, Carol Pata, and Barbara Carpentier—sit down with Christina and Annie to share how faith and friendship have shaped their lives. From Bible study to daily Mass routines, pilgrimage bracelets to bereavement ministry, these “Soul Sisters” reveal how laughter, service, and total trust in God sustain them through joy and hardship. A warm, funny, and tender conversation about living faith out loud.

In this heartfelt episode of Holy Banter, Abby and Dexter share a moving story of faith, honest communication, joyful engagement, and the profound reality of love after loss.Abby reflects on how her late husband Kyle continues to shape her understanding of marriage, while Dexter embraces their new beginning with grace and steadfast commitment. Together, they remind us that one love doesn’t replace another — it generously expands.Join Christina and Annie for a tender and inspiring conversation with Abby and Dexter as they explore the sacred work of preparing for a lifetime together. 

From their Youngstown courtship to a lifetime of serving others, these loving grandparents show how small, steady practices—prayer, presence, and humor—carry a marriage. Soft laughs, simple wisdom, and a gentle nudge to trust God’s plan.

In this episode, Fr. Matthew Kalu shares his remarkable journey from rural Nigeria to parish life in Indiana. He reflects on his upbringing during the Nigerian Civil War, the influence of Irish missionaries, and the communal culture that shaped his faith. Fr. Matthew discusses the challenges and blessings of ministering in a new country, the importance of catechists in passing on the faith, and the beauty of hospitality across cultures. With humor, joy, and gratitude, he reveals how the universality of the Church connects us all—from village compounds in Nigeria to Coffee and Donuts in Zionsville.

Join us for a conversation with Lauren Lawson, Director of Liturgical Music, as she shares how faith and music shape her ministry. From the joy of the Children’s Choir to the solemn beauty of the Service of Shadows, Lauren reflects on building community through worship, preparing for Holy Week, and the importance of hospitality in every liturgical moment.

In this heartfelt episode of Holy Banter, we sit down with Laura Shuler to explore her journey of faith, community, and parenting within the Catholic Church. Laura opens up about the joys and challenges of raising children while nurturing a deep connection to God. She shares how her empathy shapes her ministry in religious education, the importance of building emotional connections, and the ways community support has guided her through seasons of growth and hardship.Together, we discuss the evolving role of religious education, the value of Christ-like friendships, and the courage it takes to let go as a parent and trust God. From engaging families in faith to fostering events like Journey to the Manger, Laura’s story highlights the power of community, service, and the joy found in living out one’s faith.

In this episode, we sit down with Dan Nield and Chuck Wright to explore That Man Is You, a dynamic new men's ministry launching at St. Alphonsus. Together, we unpack the power of brotherhood, the role of vulnerability in faith, and why authentic connection is essential for men seeking spiritual growth.Through honest conversation and shared personal journeys, Dan and Chuck reflect on the challenges men face in expressing emotion, building community, and deepening their relationship with Christ. Whether you’re new to men’s ministry or looking to reignite your faith, this episode offers encouragement, insight, and a compelling invitation to step out of your comfort zone.Key themes: masculinity, Catholic faith, vulnerability, community, spiritual growth, That Man Is You.

In this episode of Holy Banter, Annie and Christina welcome guests Rachel Christianson, Emily Mason, and Tish Cronin to introduce She Shall Be Called Woman—a new Catholic women’s ministry rooted in community, hospitality, and spiritual growth. Together, they discuss the vision behind the ministry, its welcoming structure, and how it creates space for meaningful fellowship, prayer, and support among women of all ages and backgrounds. Whether you're a seasoned participant in women’s groups or simply searching for a place to belong, this conversation will inspire you to step into community and deepen your faith journey.

In this episode, Deacon Tim Perry shares insights from his lifelong faith journey, beginning with a spiritual awakening in college that shaped his call to serve. He reflects on the transformative power of silent retreats and pilgrimages, and how experiences in nature—like the Boundary Waters—cultivate gratitude and resilience. Deacon Perry also discusses the sacred responsibilities of a deacon, from preparing homilies and accompanying catechumens to the Easter Vigil, to guiding parishioners through end-of-life planning. A thoughtful conversation on servant leadership, spiritual formation, and the everyday call to live the Gospel.

In this inspiring conversation, Justin Clark opens up about his journey of faith and conversion to Catholicism, discussing the challenges and joys of raising a family while navigating his spiritual path. He emphasizes the importance of community support, the role of prayer, and the significance of understanding Catholic teachings. Justin's insights reflect a deep commitment to his faith and a desire to grow spiritually alongside his family.

In this episode, Christina and Annie sit down with long-time parishioner Kate Shay to revisit the powerful testimony she shared at the Parish Revival. Kate reflects on what mission looks like in her everyday life, showing that evangelization doesn’t have to be intimidating. With heartfelt stories from Daily Mass, the gym, and her volunteer work, she highlights the beauty of simple presence, listening well, and calling others by name. Tune in for an inspiring conversation about how living your faith authentically creates quiet but profound ripple effects in the lives of those around you.

In this uplifting episode, Laura Graefnitz—Catholic mother of six and dedicated health coach—shares her journey of nurturing both body and soul. From her roots in a large, faith-filled family to her current role in health coaching and community ministry, Laura offers wisdom on the importance of self-care, healthy eating, and finding joy in movement through SoulCore. She also reflects on the beauty of Vacation Bible School and its role in bringing faith to life for children and families. Join us as we explore how faith, parenting, and wellness intertwine to build a vibrant life of purpose and connection.

In this inspiring episode of Holy Banter, Christina and Annie sit down with Andrea Simpson, whose career path took a surprising turn—from practicing law to serving in middle school ministry. Andrea shares how her faith guided her through a season of professional discernment, what it's like to work with teens and preteens, and the powerful ways God called her into a deeper mission. Her story is a heartfelt reminder that no matter where we start, God can lead us to unexpected and fulfilling places.Whether you're discerning a change in your own life or just love a good testimony, this episode will leave you encouraged and uplifted.

In this episode of Holy Banter, we sit down with Father Travis Stephens to learn more about the man behind the collar. From his vocation story to surprising hobbies, it’s a casual, heartfelt conversation that helps us see the human side of our pastor. Whether you know him well or are just getting acquainted, you’ll come away with a deeper appreciation for his journey of faith and joy in ministry.

This special episode captures the wonder, excitement, and faith of two of our First Communicants as they prepare their hearts and share what this sacrament means to them. it's a beautiful glimpse into their spiritual journey and love for the Blessed Sacrament.