All episodes

S5 Ep17: The Ghost Prickler

S5 Ep16: This Murder Was Stupid

Patreon Preview: The X-Files Pilot

S5 Ep15: Allegedly Not Mysterious

S5 Ep14: More Potato Content, Please!

S5 Ep13: Murder Sounds

Patreon Preview: Forensic Files

S5 Ep12: Ignorant and Delusional

S5 Ep11: Keep Barking

S5 Ep10: RIP Auto Zone

S5 Ep9: Death By Coconut Crab

S5 Ep8: Hello Yankee Boys

S5 Ep7: A Questionable Enterprise

S5 Ep6: My Favorite Pickled Onion

S5 Ep5: A Woman Of Mystery

S5 Ep4: Mustache Brigade

Patreon Preview: The Mothman of Point Pleasant

S5 Ep3: Assassin Talk and Baby X

S5 Ep2: Corn Tassel

S5 Ep1: Don’t Worry We’re Solving Mysteries

Season 4 Finale: Listener Stories

S4 Ep25: Drugs and Investments

S4 Ep24: The Squirrel’s Alibi

S4 Ep23: The Diabolical Mind Condition

S4 Ep22: Others Disagree

2019 Holiday Special: Eau De Corpse (Beyond Belief Fact or Fiction)

S4 Ep21: A Skeleton Wearing Boots

S4 Ep20: Let Your Conscience Be Your Guide (100th Episode!)

S4 Ep19: Don’t Commit M-Arson

S4 Ep18: Dr. No

Patreon Preview: Ghost Adventures

S4 Ep17: The Abominably Smelly Man

S4 Ep16: Depressing As All Get Out

S4 Ep15: The Royal Canadian Mustache Police

S4 Ep14: This Boat Sucked

S4 Ep13: Crimes in the Past Were Just Crafts

S4 Ep12: A Vaguely Mysterious Man

Bonus! Patreon Episode! Behind the Curve (Flat Earth Documentary)

S4 Ep11: Surprisingly Consistent

S4 Ep10: Living Life from One Shoulder Pad to Another

S4 Ep9: Don’t Be a Jerk, Murderers!

S4 Ep8: A Detective in Some Mystery

S4 Ep7: Where Friendships Go to Die

S4 Ep6: Men Being the Absolute Worst Part 2

Hero Dog Pupcast 4: Elect Some Dogs

S4 Ep5: Men Being the Absolute Worst

S4 Ep4: The Worst Episode Yet!

S4 Ep3: This Gets Weird Real Quick

S4 Ep2: My Kingdom for a Yeti

S4 Ep1: Demon in a Bottle

Season 3 Finale: Listener Stories

S3 Ep22: Flim Flam Floma Disease

Hero Dog Pupcast 3: In Which a Cat has a More Impressive Resume than Us

S3 Ep21: A Dramatic Lab Coat Removal

S3 Ep20: Made-Up Quackery Stuff

S3 Ep19: Snail Mail Troll

S3 Ep18: The Mystery Shaft

S3 Ep17: Murder Confession Hotline

S3 Ep16: 1870’s Weirdo

S3 Ep15: Find a Woman to Blame

Hero Dog Pupcast 2: In Which We Learn About Pigeon Fanciers

S3 Ep14: An Alien Named Kevin

S3 Ep13: Champagne Floats

S3 Ep12: Everything is Real!

S3 Ep11: Mr. Stack is Right

S3 Ep10: Sheriff Lumpkin

2018 Holiday Special: Local Ghost Stories

Hero Dog Pupcast 1: In Which Liz Learns about Balto

S3 Ep9: Hero Dog Stories

S3 Ep8: Hex The Patriarchy

S3 Ep7: Reverse Mothman

Happy Thanksgiving! Beyond Belief: Fact or Fiction

S3 Ep6: Nature’s Whimsy

S3 Ep5: Country Club Rage

S3 Ep4: A Computer Genius Run Amok

S3 Ep3: The Pressure to have a Mustache Was Great

S3 Ep2: The Triangle of Death

S3 Ep1: True, But Rude

1 Year Anniversary Special: Yo-Ho-Ho and a Bottle of Dumb

Season 2: Q&A

Season 2 Finale: Listener Stories

S2 Ep19: Assassinations Were all the Rage

S2 Ep18: Karma This Out

S2 Ep17: It’s Lake Monster Time!

S2 Ep16: Slenderma’am

S2 Ep15: I’m a Hedgehog Truther

S2 Ep14: Eating Snacks and Taking Naps

S2 Ep13: The Amnesia Thing Again

Bonus! June Patreon Episode! Beyond Belief: Fact or Fiction

S2 Ep12: Scorpion Country

S2 Ep11: Boss Crump

S2 Ep10: The Porpoise of Justice

S2 Ep9: Spooky Trench Coat Magazine

S2 Ep8: Everything is Awful

S2 Ep7: Such a Cute Mystery

S2 Ep6: Hitler and his Bros

S2 Ep5: Are Vampires Real?

S2 Ep4: The Actor Who Played His Mustache

S2 Ep3: Donner Party on the Ocean

S2 Ep2: Trust No Rustys